Related videos by Shutterstock

19 comments

Guest's picture
Guest

What the hell?

A) Troy wasn't in the desert.
B) TERRIBLE execution, shadows missing on legs, Dust cloud looks terrible, ground is weird.

Guest's picture
Guest

Nice idea, although very bad photoshoping, it just don't look good enough.

Guest's picture
Guest

good idea,but not good art work.

Guest's picture
Guest

What the... troy, sand storm, since when?

Guest's picture
Guest

...Do people on here even know what Miami Ad School is? This was done by students. Thus, no budget, no re-touchers, none of the fancy shmancy agency stuff to make your work look better than it really is. That being considered, I think it's great!

agwbl's picture
agwbl
299 pencils

Yes, I agree. You must allow for a lack of slickness to a piece of student work. That being considered, I think that it is a great idea that suffers because they tried to force a product benefit in that doesn't make sense with the subject matter. If they left it in a Greek countryside setting instead of making it in the desert it would be much improved.

Guest's picture
Guest

bad art

Guest's picture
Guest

concept is meager it best... the image looks elementary. i would expect better work coming from miami ad school!

StarlaY's picture
StarlaY
310 pencils

Nice idea, poor knowledge of history... The ancient city of Troy is quite close to sea not in the middle of the desert... That's how Greeks traveled to Troy: via ships:)
They should switch the noah's ark headline with The Troy one... because you know most sources say, the arc is somewhere on the mount ararat, eastern Anatolia... where there's no floods or water anymore but dust :)

“Inspiration exists, but it has to find us working.” Picasso.

Guest's picture
Guest

Well if you look closely u will find an ocean on the left top side of the image.

StarlaY's picture
StarlaY
310 pencils

oh so it's a beach then, not a desert :D

“Inspiration exists, but it has to find us working.” Picasso.

Guest's picture
Guest

well at least it looks like one ;)

ultraboon222's picture
ultraboon222
220 pencils

Okay, although you are correct that Troy is near the sea, this ad is about how this Trojan horse has been there so long that the near by beach has turned into a desert. It's just like the Arc one. A Hyperbole....come on people!

Too many cooks in the kitchen....

StarlaY's picture
StarlaY
310 pencils

oh come on! a hyperbole?? The trojan horse which is by the sea (not really, Troy is located 3-4 kms away from the beach to be precise) in the future is so well protected until the beach has turned into desert???? welcome to the planet of the apes... also, the arc is somewhere on a mountain in the present day but if the horse ad is about future like a post apocalyptic scene, the signals get mixed.

“Inspiration exists, but it has to find us working.” Picasso.

Guest's picture
Guest

lovely concept... good goin

Guest's picture
Guest

Its a Beach, with the sea on its back, nicely done, great execution...but, Noahs Arc is way BETTER

Guest's picture
Guest

Kinda cool for a students. Also I agree - Be careful. Stupid mistakes (like the Troy in the desert) can destroy good idea. Especially when you are from states so everyone will make jokes at your geography and history knowledge :))

And if i were you i would fight with the copy. It's too descriptive for me.

but still - i like the idea a lot

Guest's picture
Guest

IT is a picture of a beach it is very obvious in the background but the sandstorm is covering most of it.
I dig

thekori's picture
thekori
2 pencils

nice design... troy from çanakkale / Turkey

Post new comment

Thank you for commenting. Please do not spam, be elaborate, respectful and helpful.
Log in or register to post comments