Dinodia Photo Library: Bhopal gas

...
Dinodia Photo Library
Every picture is worth a thousand words
Since 1987

A shocking description of the Bhopal gas tragedy that happened in 1984. I didn't count the words, but I suspect it is exactly a thousand words.

Agency: Leo Burnett, Mumbai, India
Creative Director: K.V.Sridhar, Santosh Padhi
Copywriter: Russell Barrett
Art Director: Santosh Padhi
Photographer: Dinodia Photo Library
Illustrator: Bhushan Patil
Typographer: Santosh Padhi

6 comments

MADE in the USA's picture
MADE in the USA
434 pencils

Nice demonstration of metaphor. subtle coloring.

Mabakima's picture
Mabakima
84 pencils

This reminds me of the Time (or is it Newsweek?)ad wherein words formed iconic photos of the 20th century. Anyhow, I think the opening paragraphs should tell the story first of the dead child in the photo rather than telling about the tragedy, much like how a short story starts. The copy as is doesn't grip you enough at the opening for you to read all the thousand or so words.

writergeekdez's picture
writergeekdez
255 pencils

I read the entire thing. It was incredibly sad. If this was for a charity that fought against companies and governments, like those responsible here, I'd be on their website making a donation.

Too good of an ad for a photo library.

ivan's picture
ivan

It's what Benetton used to do. Sell their products through highlighting a social issue.

Ivan Raszl, admin of AotW

Oxo's picture
Oxo
52 pencils

Damn. I feel lied to.
I was hoping the ad was for some NGO with a deeper objective, than just a regular capitalist group that want to sell photos to us. And the "Since 1987" makes it worse.
I feel using such an intense picture and text for a superficial thing is disrespectful.

Indra Sinha's picture
Indra Sinha
32 pencils

The worst thing about this ad is its dishonesty. If you search the Dinodia Photo Library you will find 24 mediocre colour shots of tourist attractions in Bhopal. You will not find Raghu Rai's famous and gruelling image of the baby's burial the morning after the Bhopal disaster. Dinodia owns no rights to this image, which is licensed through Magnum. It certainly has no right to use it in this way, in a pretence of compassion to serve a commercial end.

I know this picture well. In 1993, I phoned Raghu and asked his permission to use it to launch the Bhopal Medical Appeal. For a year it remained pinned to my wall as I struggled to find words to match it. I could not bear to have any words on the same page, not even the photographer's credit. The ad had to become a double page spread. The picture was by itself on the left and the copy on the right hand page opened with the story Raghu told me over the phone about how he and Pablo Bartholomew had found this man burying his child. How they had both taken pictures and how both hardened news photographers had cried.

There is a tenderness in this picture which transcends the horror, and makes it great. Raghu told me how the father had covered over the baby's head with earth, but then, as if unwilling to let her go, had brushed away the dirt for one last look. This is why there is dust on the eyeballs of the baby.

On the 10th anniversary of the disaster I launched the Bhopal Medical Appeal with Raghu's own story of what his camera had not been able to capture. There were at least 1,000 words on that right hand page, and they were barely enough to begin to tell the story of what had happened in Bhopal and how people were still suffering. A proper newspaper article would have had three times as many.

Thousands of people must have read every word, because the ad raised enough money to enable us to buy a building in Bhopal, hire medical staff and open a free clinic. Fourteen years later that clinic has expanded to a new site in two acres of medicinal herb garden, employs more than 40 staff and has given free treatment to approaching 30,000 people. Throughout it has been funded by money raised from individuals via advertisements that tell detailed stories. These ads must first pay for themselves before they can even begin to fund the clinic.

I have sent Ivan some of the more recent Bhopal Medical Appeal ads and I believe he intends to publish them here.

Log in or register to post comments