Advertisement

Comments (26)

Log in or register to post comments

Highest Rated

yankee-sierra's picture
yankee-sierra
Activity Score 14

WAIT, AN ARGENTINIAN WHO WORKS IN EL SALVADOR IS ABOUT TO MAKE A COPYCAT OF THIS SAME VISUAL FOR AN AIRLINE. COMING SOON!!!!

Guest's picture
Guest

Done before. God, they don't have Advertising books in India ?

StarlaY's picture
StarlaY
Activity Score 310

you still use advertising books over there? The rest of the world, including India went online 15 years ago.

“Inspiration exists, but it has to find us working.” Picasso.

Guest's picture
Guest

yup , done before, if i remember it was Audi back in the 80's

akshaysrikar's picture
akshaysrikar
Activity Score 420

the headline fits good only for this particular art. the other two don't go that well. and the photoshop is .......meh..

a lot more than this is expected from rediffusion. plus idea aint all that original. but it could work for the local audience.

SoCH_TO's picture
SoCH_TO
Activity Score 961

Old Idea !!!

totally inspire to >>>

Volkswagen TVC ad

http://www.afaqs.com/advertising/creative_showcase/index.html?id=23704...

Live with Passion

LeeHarvey's picture
LeeHarvey
Activity Score 3045

Thanks for the link SonuChandra. Clear, done, period.

shortafella's picture
shortafella
Activity Score 1063

I have seen this so many times before. And it's boring too...

KbxAds's picture
KbxAds
Activity Score 943

this idea is being done in a current TVC by Volkswagen running in India, how can you release such an idea?

Ferra22's picture
Ferra22
Activity Score 2

first idea

ilovegreatads's picture
ilovegreatads
Activity Score 312

a piece of advice for the team: go out and play.
no, guys, no.

himanshu prabhakar's picture
himanshu prabhakar
Activity Score 471

Nice! but you used left Hand only !! why ?
Mr. Prasant Bhor

Himanshu Prabhakar

tirthomitro's picture
tirthomitro
Activity Score 2758

guys! show a single idea from the last 50 archive pages of AoTW
that is a "non-repetition".
besides, there is client pressure for "GOOD ads". and sometimes we know that it means
take an existing idea and "do" it in a diff. way.
But in the end Yes... in the days when people do "research", does it mean there is nothing left to "search" ???

they showed me a picture & i laughed
dignity has never been photographed

Lazarus's picture
Lazarus
Activity Score 1536

This is no different than some Matchbox ads I saw. But I think those were scam so what the hell.

Guest's picture
Guest

You know what's been done before? The "done" comment. People post it with the fervor of a third grader who has seen someones underpants, posters (some) here are as fake as half of these ads that never run.

By the way, the examples of "done" are bogus. The concept is of a kid playing with his trucks in the mud. The VW concept is similar only in the use of the hand, not the intent and the matchbox ad (aside from being off target spec) was the inverse application with a different meaning.

Billoughsby's picture
Billoughsby
Activity Score 5144

BING BING BING -- We have a comment worth reading! Somebody had to say it. Good for you.

"Ubi hubave lubearned thubat ubanuby fubool cuban wrubite uba bubad ubad, bubut thubat ubit tubakes uba rubeal gubenubiubus tubo kubeep hubis hubands uboff uba gubood ubone."
-Lubeo Buburnubett

Guest's picture
Guest

I kinda agree with you. Kinda.

mdb1974's picture
mdb1974
Activity Score 411

Agree!

michelangelo's picture
michelangelo
Activity Score 660

Even if was already "done" before, if they spent more time on art direction and retouching, it would have come out a lot more brilliantly than those "done" ads from the past since this one has a better insight

Guest's picture
Guest

Guys, although the visuals of the ads you wrote about in the comments above seem similar to this ad, actually the idea itself strikes me as a bit different, so technically, it is not the idea that is being re-used, but the "visual means", so to say... And to be honest, the Indian Oil Xtramile: Play seems to be the best regarding both the use, and the implementation of the idea. So, I think it is really good. And, yes, which idea implemenet over the last 50 years cannot be found anywhere else?

Guest's picture
Guest

yeah wake up done many times before

Dharmesh aka danny's picture
Dharmesh aka danny
Activity Score 334

It clearly displays the clients desire and not the creative team.

Dharmesh Padia

yankee-sierra's picture
yankee-sierra
Activity Score 14

WAIT, AN ARGENTINIAN WHO WORKS IN EL SALVADOR IS ABOUT TO MAKE A COPYCAT OF THIS SAME VISUAL FOR AN AIRLINE. COMING SOON!!!!

Advertisement