pretty good's picture
pretty good
364 pencils

I like it. It should read "people", not "persons", but I like it.

Mr.Top's picture
728 pencils

I dont like it... you use tragedies that have nothing to do with the water problem only to show how many 8 million people are?

Plus the result on the ad is a glass of clear water. Shouldn't be muddy or toxic water?

The whole thing doesnt make any sense.

iT-iS-i's picture
1721 pencils

Couldn't put it better even if I tried... Same sentiments shared here mate.

Who turned the world upside down?

:: Put your ears against the ground so i can walk over what you heard::

vwray81's picture
256 pencils


Zlyuk's picture
128 pencils

It's not funny, but make me smile...
Cool design and bad idea.

teenie's picture
1894 pencils

I do believe they're trying to say that we pay a lot more attention to the Titanic and 9/11 than to preventable diseases caused by non-potable water. This ad is badly translated and they've made it more complicated than it should be, but I like the sentiment. Millions of children die every year of treatable diseases from dirty water - but people would rather give money to 9/11 families. Not that any giving is wrong, but media focus is skewed and we've turned off our sensitivity to 3rd world countries.

rainman's picture
267 pencils

exactly, but I think they did a decent job of translating it up until the water part. It should be dirtier to get the point across more.

ecflagcorp's picture
108 pencils

What? I don't get it. Are you saying that if I don't drink water I'll die? Titantic and 9/11 in this ad is morally wrong. You could have come at it with a totally different angle.

Luis Maram's picture
Luis Maram
252 pencils

I agree Teenie. In Africa millions of children die every year of treatable diseases from dirty water... but that tragedy isn't in TV every day so we accept it like normal.

Related the ad, ok, i undestand the idea but the execution is bad. 9/11 is a difficult issue to explore in advertising... even social adv.

ricklongo's picture
1244 pencils

The line of thinking is nice, but the equation doesn't make any sense, because a glassof clean water can't be used to represent the lack of clean water.

Tincho's picture
1093 pencils

Does anyone know how they do those numbers? or what soft do they use?

Nice campaing by the way.

panasit's picture
687 pencils

If they can back up those numbers, then the situation is worse than 9/11 and Titanic. So I think it's justify for them to "upset us". The math is there.

--good idea is enemy of great idea

capywriter's picture
5509 pencils

My only problem is the glass of 'clean' water. On the other hand... even polluted water can look quite clear...

whoberee's picture
55 pencils

Since everyone's being so literal...just because the glass of water looks clean, doesn't mean it can't contain bacteria that can kill and even dirty looking water can be safe to drink. I have no problem with this ad, and actually think it's great. Regardless of your position on the morality of this execution, we all reacted to it. And isn't that the point of PSA ads, to stir our emotions and make us want to take action?

gracey's picture
100 pencils

cool design, bad idea to use a ship wreakage

pankajadsoftheworld's picture
433 pencils

Wonderful execution liked alot

vekialvivo's picture
32 pencils

The art and concept are great. I totally love them, there is only one big mistake in execution. It actually says that 2,000 times titanic and 911 is equal to a glass of water??? That doesn't make sense. It still works because of the copy and because we change it in our minds to sya what it is supposed to say: that those tragedies equal the same as LACK of water. So, at least, if you want to keep it like this the glass should be empty in order for it to make sense.

Guest's picture

no. it's saying that if you take the number of people who died when the titanic sank and add the number of people who died in the attack of september 11 and then multiply that number by 2000... you get the number of humans who die each year from infected water. the irony is that so many more people die from polluted water than died on the titanic or at 911 but no one cares or talks about those deaths because they aren't spectacular. people subscribe to hype and they need to be "offended" to shake them out of their trance...

Guest's picture

i like it a lot.. ITS A GREAT AD. everybody else is just jealous..

Guest's picture

The math is wrong... Under these circumstances u do the X first and only after that u do the +.

Log in or register to post comments