Advertisement

Comments (36)

Log in or register to post comments

Highest Rated

ravikanth's picture
ravikanth

the execution is simply superb but the texture appears to me like that of a girrafe.

justpassingby's picture
justpassingby
Activity Score 1368

these are brilliant. hats off to you

slim's picture
slim
Activity Score 1047

There is no place on Earth that looks like this from above.

sonal dabral's picture
sonal dabral
Activity Score 22

There is no place on this Earth that looks fit for cynics like you. I like this ad.

slim's picture
slim
Activity Score 1047

Good for you. It doesn't change the fact that this is one good idea (Leopard) and two mangled ad-wrecks (this and Tiger). I could go on pointing out the problems with each ... the ridiculous-looking shadows and unnaturally bent trees in Tiger, the illogically brown patches of dirt in Snake ... but I suspect I would be wasting my time. I'm more curious to discover why you're such a fan of these. Wouldn't have anything to do with the fact that they came from your old agency would it? These aren't your mate's ads, are they? Looking to get your grubby little name on them as ECD, perhaps?

To even suggest such things, now that truly would be cynical.

PaulyG_fill in the blank's picture
PaulyG_fill in ...
Activity Score 1148

I don't know where you got that info from. Let's not make up facts and figures here - 80.67% of people don't like it.

chintan ruparel's picture
chintan ruparel
Activity Score 1516

80.67% hehehe

~ old habits die hard, older ones never do ~

slim's picture
slim
Activity Score 1047

My first assertion, about him once working for O&M Mumbai, is a known fact. The second and third are just speculation. A bit of harmless pot-stirring.

PaulyG_fill in the blank's picture
PaulyG_fill in ...
Activity Score 1148

I was more referring to your comment that there's no place on earth that looks like that. Earth is a pretty big place.

JCHS's picture
JCHS
Activity Score 67

Theres a similar campaign from DDB spain concept was every city has a wild side. reminds of that, and who cares who havent done an ad with maps seen from above?

sonal dabral's picture
sonal dabral
Activity Score 22

You can't speak English right, what the bloody hell are you talking about?

PaulyG_fill in the blank's picture
PaulyG_fill in ...
Activity Score 1148

Hey buddy. "You can't speak proper English. What the bloody hell are you talking about?" That's how it should have been said.

You made one of the most egregious errors in English - a comma splice. You separated two complete sentences with a comma. Get your own shit together before you start degrading others.

JCHS's picture
JCHS
Activity Score 67

First of, all I dont, give a flying f...k if my, english is bad I dont like this ,ad bc i ve seen ,better like this ,ad for audi, from DDB spain. Who the f...k are you ,anyway i ,can say ,what i, think,,, any time, i feel like it ,,,and i can put all the comas,,, i want to ,,,so you get your shit together.

msred's picture
msred
Activity Score 491

stop fighting. tis silly.

PaulyG_fill in the blank's picture
PaulyG_fill in ...
Activity Score 1148

I wasn't even talking to you pal. I was talking to the guy who was making fun of someone's English. So just take it easy.

PaulyG_fill in the blank's picture
PaulyG_fill in ...
Activity Score 1148

I would never make fun of someone's English, and that's why I made the comment. Sonal is making fun of someone, when his English isn't even correct. It certainly wasn't directed at you. It upsets me when people come on here and make stabs at people for no good reason.

adoholic's picture
adoholic
Activity Score 8

Dear Slim,

Are you an astronaut or what? There’s a thing called creative freedom in this world. And by the way, why don’t u post some of your ads and let us judge them…

slim's picture
slim
Activity Score 1047

Sonal, Adaholic - is it cynical to point out that an ad isn't working so well (IMHO) because the idea relies on a forced execution? The primary purpose of this site is to get feedback on ads so that we can all get better at producing them. That's all I was doing. If you disagree with me, tell me why. Don't make it personal.

And Sonal, having a go at someone's poor English on a website with people contributing from all over the world is pretty poor form. Especially when your own comment is grammatically questionable.

adthtsucks's picture
adthtsucks
Activity Score 56

slim ur feedback can never improve anyones creativity. and who r u to improve others. show ur works let others comment on it, may be u can improve ur stuffs.

slim's picture
slim
Activity Score 1047

What a waste of time......

jennywhx's picture
jennywhx
Activity Score 1142

I seriously just don't understand why people like to argue here, especially on "who speaks proper english?".
Does this site only open for people who from US or england or watever place that english as their main language?
Is it really SO important that to comment in "proper english?", the meaning of comment is the content itself or the grammar?
I admit my english is bad, but i don't want to make it a barrier for me to communicate with the world,

if only people who know how to speak proper english can talk, then i can only say i am very disappointed to the world.
Can anyone please stop critic about grammar or language mistake here? Does it really matter
?
I am sorry i am not posting about comment here, but this is my little wish that i seriously hate to see nonsense argue about grammar anymore.

http://jennywhx.blogspot.com jwhx:Visionary

chintan ruparel's picture
chintan ruparel
Activity Score 1516

HAHAHAHA!!! im havin fun man...go on

~ old habits die hard, older ones never do ~

sheetalz's picture
sheetalz
Activity Score 146

Thank you so much Jenny. HATZZ OFF for u.
i like this campaign.

fifthbullet's picture
fifthbullet
Activity Score 186

agreed... why pick on language when we r here for the mind.
use consumer language is one of the good way to communicate with audience,
who give a damn on a ad that is perfect in the grammar,
while the layman cannot get the "idea" totally...

msred's picture
msred
Activity Score 491

i love AotW

justpassingby's picture
justpassingby
Activity Score 1368

we all want to see slims ads.
go on mate, get your ads out for the boys and girls.

slim's picture
slim
Activity Score 1047

I'll be submitting some shortly. And you?

justpassingby's picture
justpassingby
Activity Score 1368

im not a creative but im ready to judge, i might even be your target audience.

fifthbullet's picture
fifthbullet
Activity Score 186

hehe... just make sure u don't act like a typical know-it-all client ok. :P

slim's picture
slim
Activity Score 1047

lemme get this right:

You want to see my work b/c you believe that those who judge must also be able to do.

You admit that you can't do yourself, but you're quite happy to judge.

?????

justpassingby's picture
justpassingby
Activity Score 1368

aim of advertising is to sell to the public not to win awards.

im the public, show me what you got. No need to be defensive, we might love what you show us

slim's picture
slim
Activity Score 1047

I'm just curious why you're so keen to see my work in particular.

justpassingby's picture
justpassingby
Activity Score 1368

read the thread.

slim's picture
slim
Activity Score 1047

I want to hear you say it.

justpassingby's picture
justpassingby
Activity Score 1368

you sound like my bloody girlfriend

jolie's picture
jolie
Activity Score 30

I think it would be really nice if people kept their personal differences and egos aside and comment on the work. And yes people can have different opinions as long as they have a strong reasoning behind it. This is a forum where people should engage in healthy discussion of work and not personal bickering. And could anyone please tell me where have they seen something like this before.
Anyways, I think this campaign is really awesome and very well brings out the importance of protecting forests to protect wildlife. Ofcourse all of us have seen a lot of campaigns addressing this issue but this execution is really fresh. Great goin.........

ravikanth's picture
ravikanth

the execution is simply superb but the texture appears to me like that of a girrafe.

Advertisement