Papakura District Council: School Photo
Average: 7 (56 votes)

Advertising Agency: Ogilvy, Auckland, New Zealand
Group Heads: Martin Hermans, Richard Loseby
Executive Creative Director: Damon O'Leary
Art Director: Freddie Coltart
Copywriter: Matt Williams
Photographer: Meek
Retoucher: Adrian Fitzgerald
Via: bestadsontv

29 comments

Anonymous Author's picture
1545 pencils
Anonymous Author

Strong community message, particularly if that is an actual victim. Kudos and condolences to family if so.

Write a wise saying and your name will live forever – Anonymous.

http://www.anonymousauthor.co.nz
www.twitter.com/@anonauth

atb2005's picture
13639 pencils
atb2005

I doubt that's an actual victim. The message would be even stronger if that was the case though. In any event, great ad!

abake's picture
1164 pencils
abake

Great ad.

Roger Keynes's picture
5399 pencils
Roger Keynes

Subtly unsettling. Job done.

Will Think for Salary

mmackinven's picture
1406 pencils
mmackinven

Nice, like :) Go Loseby!!!

Jaap Grolleman's picture
6926 pencils
Jaap Grolleman

Lovely. Funny how he's the only one smiling =)

Lucylu's picture
109 pencils
Lucylu

Yes, that bit caught my eye too. A good effort.

Guest's picture
Guest

They get to wear sneakers at school awesome... I love the ad its great!

Guest's picture
Guest

Oh come on! It 's a dead kid among alive kids... very touching but where is the creativity???

bloomonkey's picture
99 pencils
bloomonkey

I like the toning in the ad, it looks really bleak and sinister which I think adds to the impact.

"Never try teaching a pig to sing, its a waste of time and annoys the pig" - Robert Heinlein

Elmārs Ārnieks's picture
840 pencils
Elmārs Ārnieks

nice

Life is a joke. Laugh.

Psicowalrus's picture
13 pencils
Psicowalrus

no creativity at all.

Matt Tonkin's picture
168 pencils
Matt Tonkin

How so? It's creative in that it makes you take a second to think it over before you completely understand it. It's creative because it doesn't specifically state the absent child died, it is implied by the line and the sad faces. Just because it is not "flashy" overall doesn't make it uncreative.

F.Abboud's picture
218 pencils
F.Abboud

@Psicowalrus; can you just give us a description of how would you do it more creatively please; thanks.

Libor Oubrecht's picture
307 pencils
Libor Oubrecht

Where is the idea?

atb2005's picture
13639 pencils
atb2005

It's right there in the photo

elyoshiro's picture
526 pencils
elyoshiro

Very nice,

HappyHour's picture
2404 pencils
HappyHour

at first glance thought it was an ad for improving schools (the kid not there is the only one smiling and happy). interesting thought here, I'm not sure if it's believable that this is the way a school would treat a class photo had one of the children died though...

Roger Keynes's picture
5399 pencils
Roger Keynes

oh ffs... if half you guys had stayed in school long enough to be in your own school/class photos... you'd know that any student that is away from school that day is still noted/included.

Will Think for Salary

keithstoeckeler's picture
425 pencils
keithstoeckeler

Very well communicated and great tone for a print ad.

silvi's picture
4172 pencils
silvi

Shocking, strong message.

thedesignaddict's picture
4834 pencils
thedesignaddict

Effective + memorable.

Guest's picture
Guest

Nice work

Guest's picture
Guest

As an auckland kiwi I have to say the grey dark tones really does remind me of Papakura.....

Great add :>

bobby666's picture
1434 pencils
bobby666

masterpiece of an ad. it really made me think twice and filled me with compassion. superb guys.

Guest's picture
Guest

Would have worked without the picture of the dead dude too. TAKE IT OFF! TAKE IT OFF!

Dzsoi's picture
5009 pencils
Dzsoi

Very strong, emotional and I love the straight, human tone of the copy. Good thinking, man!

Guest's picture
Guest

too literal?

babaonwww's picture
24 pencils
babaonwww

its really great... strong message.... memorable..... this ad will remind them when reach near school school I like it...
This is the creativity it can hold audience's heart.