44 comments

morse's picture
11778 pencils
morse

Really nice ad, but I would not feed a small baby with Oreo. I know many do.

.. / .-.. --- ...- . / .- -.. ...- . .-. - .. ... .. -. --.

Spanky's picture
4795 pencils
Spanky

Scam ad. I don't see this making it through Nabisco. And there's nothing for Oreo on their site.

thedesignaddict's picture
4857 pencils
thedesignaddict

Unexpected and relevant. Nice photo too.

kalankji's picture
219 pencils
kalankji

irrelevant unethical

thenikcreative's picture
17 pencils
thenikcreative

Are you guys kidding? As an OREO fan I find this ad absolutely fantastic. The art direction is great - the look in the babies eyes is priceless … well done Cheil.

Ramat Ajala's picture
469 pencils
Ramat Ajala

C'mon, the same was done for a milk brand years ago, very famous and won Cannes.

Hadrons's picture
5644 pencils
Hadrons

Simply not pleasant. Nor appealing .

(Are you going to have a nice warm cup of mother's milk with your cookie now ?)

THERE'S NO HEAVIER BURDEN THAN A GREAT POTENTIAL

kleenex's picture
16760 pencils
kleenex

Why not????

Prasad Weerasekara's picture
624 pencils
Prasad Weerasekara

good one.

Milan Solanki's picture
984 pencils
Milan Solanki

oreo is not for infants, and by the way no kid would care for any fcuking oreo while being breastfed

Gi_bo's picture
1381 pencils
Gi_bo

I seriously doubt you work in advertising

GiBo

Milan Solanki's picture
984 pencils
Milan Solanki

Sorry buddy, if my comment offended you, it was just my perception..
: )

KrishZol's picture
10 pencils
KrishZol

I think its a fantastic ad for Oreo lover...@thenikcreative u are right, look at babie's eye and see how babee hold a Oreo with his tiny little hand.. Wel done cheil... its nice ad..

ZeSheep's picture
182 pencils
ZeSheep

There is a thin line between creative liberty and ethics. A complete fail for me

kak009's picture
17 pencils
kak009

Really sad.
Creativity has a limit. copy ZeSheep.

Temple's picture
9499 pencils
Temple

What's more repugnant than this crap is boyfriends and girlfriends of agency people coming here and praising.

arnwald's picture
42 pencils
arnwald

Yeah right...

sushil kumar swami's picture
575 pencils
sushil kumar swami

Does "Advertising Standard Council" really works or do we need any ADVERTISING POLICE? The indecent representation of women(Prohibition) Act, 1986

Sushil kumar swami | (An Advertising Illiterate) | Mumbai | (INDIA)
brand.reports@gmail.com

Wordfruit's picture
1037 pencils
Wordfruit

I don't think this is as solid as some other Oreo ads, but I think it would get attention.

sanalnileshwar's picture
42 pencils
sanalnileshwar

love it

Tom Megginson's picture
280 pencils
Tom Megginson

I like the ad. The only downside for me is the appropriation of something as beautiful and personal as breastfeeding to sell cookies. The "who would give an infant an Oreo?" complaint I find rather disingenuous, though. I can't see how this is to be taken literally.

I also suspect that this is spec work, but the idea is cute. Let's not forget that La Leche League in the USA partners with the California "Got Milk?" people. The idea of paralleling cow's milk and human milk is hardly new.

What amuses me about this thread is how shocked and offended supposed adults are by just seeing a breastfeeding image. I guess this is the reason nursing women are still subjected to social apartheid by anti-nature prudes.

picopalqlea's picture
1025 pencils
picopalqlea

I like boobs.... Oreos, not so much.

loco_artist's picture
40 pencils
loco_artist

I love the idea and the laugh out of it, but...

1. It is too provocative for my country Singapore.

2. Why would anyone feed a baby Oreo, they barely have teeth around that age. (maybe a couple?)

3. We love cow milk with Oreo, but breast milk with Oreo? HELL NO!

f_cleto's picture
26 pencils
f_cleto

is inevitable to see a copy, but something so blatant ... it is difficult. Lack of idea is a problem, and should not have space anywhere. I am opposed to these copies, and I think everyone also because the comments leave no doubt. Lousy job, a shame for advertising.

Ron Burgundy's picture
1666 pencils
Ron Burgundy

boob's favorite boob

jenn.'s picture
38 pencils
jenn.

I love that the ad before this is all about preventing childhood obesity. Oreos are one of the worst "foods" out there. Call CPS!

ScratchdCanvas's picture
30 pencils
ScratchdCanvas

For all you haters commenting on this.....when you have milk, you gotta have Oreo.

vote4pedro's picture
4641 pencils
vote4pedro

Ivan should add a section for fake ads of the world.

conceptualart's picture
2 pencils
conceptualart

hey Korean!!! u've seen this in your country? is it possible to publish this in Korea?
or just Cheil wants to have another fake grand-prix like last year from Cannes??

vote4pedro's picture
4641 pencils
vote4pedro

Korean culture is very conservative. No chance this ran. Also, they're not even a client on their site. Closest they have is a Chinese cookie, which would be a direct competitor.

chamindarathnayake's picture
381 pencils
chamindarathnayake

Ad is good.... but this kind of small kid.... :(

Chaminda Rathnayake

riyelam's picture
372 pencils
riyelam

All the guys crying out for ethics and morality should go to caves and stop watching pregnancy preventing and condom ads as those are also unethical from some point of view. As far as the ad is concerned its beautiful and if somebody is shouting that babies don't eat oreos then they should understand mouses also can't have dog as pet, ducks can't be sailors :)

ashtrinjuljim's picture
2 pencils
ashtrinjuljim

I'm a mother of 3 ...I see nothing wrong with this ad...its natural for a mother to breast feed and if that's the part u take offense to then Ur a prude plan and simple....the whole part about the baby holding the Oreo is cute and eye catching.....and as for those of u who think mothers breasts don't look like the while breast feeding guess what some moms do! Get over yourself and Ur own insecurity ....

fcostausb's picture
77 pencils
fcostausb

It's funny. Good idea. Good ad.

kleenex's picture
16760 pencils
kleenex

Well readers the TMZ website says that the ad was not supposed to go public....

http://www.tmz.com/2012/04/19/oreo-cookies-breastfeeding-ad-never-to-k...

vote4pedro's picture
4641 pencils
vote4pedro

The only surprise here is TMZ posted it. If Ivan sees this, I'd be curious to know if the agency submitted it or if he found it somewhere.

darkonc's picture
2 pencils
darkonc

In most of the world (read: outside the US), it's perfectly legal for a woman to breastfeed in public. There's nothing wrong with this ad that censoring the (unhealthy :-) image of a baby eating an Oreo cookie wouldn't fix.

John28's picture
2 pencils
John28

I would just like to say that we Europeans are laughing at the complaints regarding ethics. The fact that some of you get offended by this advertisement blows my mind.

Hadrons's picture
5644 pencils
Hadrons

THERE'S NO HEAVIER BURDEN THAN A GREAT POTENTIAL

r2rudy's picture
2 pencils
r2rudy

The first thing that came to mind was the US version of title --"Got Milk?"

tjdossey's picture
3 pencils
tjdossey

This is kinda stupid it s funny though .I give it one star just because there is no way those breast are the mothers.

Ron Burgundy's picture
1666 pencils
Ron Burgundy

haha

gallo03's picture
38 pencils
gallo03

Is it only one? Excellent art direction

art director

mangodebango's picture
19 pencils
mangodebango

Most likely spec work.

An Oreo and some boobage. How could this ad possibly be any better?

And why do I have the sudden craving for an Oreo (with some cleavage on the side)?