Related videos by Shutterstock

16 comments

Advertising Pawn's picture
Advertising Pawn
419 pencils

I usually never comment when I don't like an ad, but this is just a plain lame analogy with absolutely zero substance to ignite a proper debate and neither intent nor power to influence people's behaviour. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin's_law

http://advertisingpawn.com

_________________________________

Join the rarely updated ad orgy here: http://www.advertisingpawn.com

ccsman04's picture
ccsman04
165 pencils

But Morey... dont you see the AMAZING analogy and message that "nature" sees us as "evil dictators"??? Just ask any squirrel or baby dear... DUH!!! Come on man, get on the HATE band wagon... everone's hopping on. It doesn't matter how much these suck... actually, that's being to kind...

Guest star's picture
Guest star

yep. godwin. that's what i was thinking.
seems you guys couldn't think of real arguments for this client.
you used stock photos without developing a real concept. that's lazy.
don't put this in your book, it's an insult to every hard working creative person.
and, dear students: please don't ever mirror a picture if you can't do it in an unobtrusive way.

in a nutshell: this work is utter bullcrap.

postman's picture
postman
951 pencils

It kind of works with Bush (though it's not at all fresh or strong), but as I do know nothing about Hilter's or Osama's environmental policy (and as I suppose, most people don't do so either), these are just weak.

p&awn's picture
p&awn

this is not about environmental policies or similar, it's simply saying that nature hates you because you're such an evil person.
i bet it's gonna win a Golden Turd

postman's picture
postman
951 pencils

I somehow guessed so, but I couldn't really believe that they used such a weak connection.

Disco Munky's picture
Disco Munky
3900 pencils

Awesome!

9.8/10

These rock as a series.

Been a while since I've actually seen stuff on here that's been up to scratch.

Doin' it for the points

clamyd's picture
clamyd

fabulist.

badactinwoman's picture
badactinwoman
4 pencils

the media uses knee jerk reactions and learned, institutionalized behavior to influence the masses. most people couldn't even tell you much about adolf or osama. this isn't good enough to rate a golden turd. more like a bronzed hemorrhoid

Yr's picture
Yr
170 pencils

Great visual.
my applause to Advertising Agency: Miami Ad School/ESPM, Sao Paulo, Brazil
(:

RoyT's picture
RoyT

Are you kidding? This shit is god awful.

sold's picture
sold
3219 pencils

fraco

Paulfromcanada's picture
Paulfromcanada

Good ads elicit an immediate emotional response that drive the viewer to take some kind of action (otherwise what's the point?).

These ads only elicit a reaction of "What the f#$K" is that supposed to mean? The action is then to go to www.nrdc.org and try and figure out the connection. These ads do NRDC a great disservice. I believe the original idea has merit but the execution of it's meaning is truly "lost in translation"

I would suggest they take another run at the concept with different (read relevant) imagery.

Paul

Mecajet's picture
Mecajet
116 pencils

Ha ha ha!

How in the world does crappy student work get up here? Doesn't this stuff have to be approved by someone?

kent's picture
kent

太多错误了,作者需要考察一下,不是可以随便镜象图片,纳粹的徽章反了,胸前的铁十字也是应该在左胸的

Axl's picture
Axl
264 pencils

0/10

Post new comment

We highly appreciate your comments. When commenting please acknowledge the following guidelines: Be respectful and helpful. Do not spam or link drop.
Log in or register to post comments