Advertisement

Comments (17)

Log in or register to post comments

Highest Rated

Taylormade's picture
Taylormade
Activity Score 408

It's a snare trap. Just like the other execution is a trap. So you can trap your ideas inside the book. It's pretty simple.

ace85le's picture
ace85le
Activity Score 3939

A little boring for my taste. But's it's alright.

-------------------------------

www.scorchidentity.com

Brand Design | Logo Design | Brochure Design | Website Design | Branding Packages

pierrelastname's picture
pierrelastname
Activity Score 2869

DONE!

ivan's picture
ivan

Link or never happened! :)

Troll's picture
Troll
Activity Score 672

Excellent response Ivan.

LeeHarvey's picture
LeeHarvey
Activity Score 3045

Hmm I thought it was a laptop with a mouse attached. And mister Zarski, don't just yell DONE and do nothing. Sow us the original or forever hold your peace.

Shawali's picture
Shawali
Activity Score 8442

I like it. Don't ask me why. But I do.

No one cares about child labor, eye donation or saving the Earth: NO PSA!!! http://adsoftheworld.com/forum/135094

gioborde's picture
gioborde
Activity Score 1387

kAgree with above, a bit boring. doesnt stand above nor is it memorable. Its just.."ok". But then again, coming from an Ad School, being just "ok" is not ok.

GiBo

Galo's picture
Galo
Activity Score 446

The first one is better, clearer, but this is good too. Very nice set of ads.

bakamono's picture
bakamono
Activity Score 1002

This is bad, I don't understand why people like this. Can anyone explain why this is OK or good without using "It's ok I dont know why but it's ok"

Where is the pen or are you going write with your finger? This ad tells me very little about the product in fact all other notebooks are the same. What makes this notebook better? Two ads on the same subject line of ideas coming and going? The logo said "sketch" you forget to mention that in your copy and idea.

Make this product better than all other notebooks. I thought that what they teach you in ad college. Don't forget to learn more about your product their website is very helpful.

Choose your notebook:

Drawing

Organizing

Painting

Recording

Travelling

Writing

because therefore it is

Taylormade's picture
Taylormade
Activity Score 408

I like the other visual better. But I am impressed you managed to think up a decent second execution.

artyduran's picture
artyduran
Activity Score 1574

@bakamono. You sound like a very frustrated creative that works at a place where you have to explain everything on the ad and still consider it an ad.
This idea is simple and clear: Tie your ideas up, so they don't go away. I like it. It's also hard to find a unique selling proposition that differentiates this from other sketchpads, so I like the fact that these guys worked out a nice positioning for the product. Advertising is not about making a product better, it's about making people think your product is better.

And by the way, you CAN sketch out an idea.

HTG¡'s picture
HTG¡
Activity Score 38

YEAH!

VampAd's picture
VampAd
Activity Score 1151

Cool. I like it.

Billoughsby's picture
Billoughsby
Activity Score 5144

We have reached a point where we need a statement from the authors, because I liked it a lot better when I thought it was a laptop with a mouse -- the only likely visual reading of this setup -- and before I learned it might actually be an exhortation to "tie up your ideas". The insinuation that this is what you ought to be playing with instead of the internet is resonant enough on it's own to run with. The suggestion to use a book ribbon to lasso your ideas -- nah.

"Ubi hubave lubearned thubat ubanuby fubool cuban wrubite uba bubad ubad, bubut thubat ubit tubakes uba rubeal gubenubiubus tubo kubeep hubis hubands uboff uba gubood ubone."
-Lubeo Buburnubett

Taylormade's picture
Taylormade
Activity Score 408

It's a snare trap. Just like the other execution is a trap. So you can trap your ideas inside the book. It's pretty simple.

macluvin's picture
macluvin
Activity Score 397

There's a fun idea here, but the tagline doesn't seem strong enough. I would've have said something along the lines of "don't let your ideas get away" or something.

Ivan - can you ban this spammer above? So lame.

fotdot's picture
fotdot
Activity Score 673

Student work not bad.

Advertisement