Advertisement

Comments (21)

Log in or register to post comments

Highest Rated

Ed Rapport's picture
Ed Rapport
Activity Score 724

So what if it's been done before.. if this is a students work, great job..

Adaddicted's picture
Adaddicted
Activity Score 3435

Joe La Pompe around???

withalltherespects

Axl's picture
Axl
Activity Score 266

Already done done and redone...Chinese people!

Shawali's picture
Shawali
Activity Score 8442

Why even bother posting these?

No one cares about child labor, eye donation or saving the Earth: NO PSA!!! http://adsoftheworld.com/forum/135094

dellsheng's picture
dellsheng
Activity Score 21

it is just a student's work,i just need a oppotunity of being a intern at shanghai's 4A advertising agency.
and i agree it is boring.

创意不好 但对于我一个学生来说 执行力应该还可以吧 我想要去4a实习的机会 希望能认识更多朋友 谢谢大家

Oso89's picture
Oso89
Activity Score 73

I dont think this is a bad for a student, good work especially for the art direction.

PS: Im also a student, you should upload this on the students section for other kind of comments

Oso89's picture
Oso89
Activity Score 73

I dont think this is a bad for a student, good work especially for the art direction.

PS: Im also a student, you should upload this on the students section for other kind of comments

AssassinX's picture
AssassinX
Activity Score 1329

Nice photoshop work, congrats.
Yeah the idea is notoriously over-done but I think it's a good student work especially in China.
So far as I know, some big agencies just set their regional offices in Shanghai, eg. BBH, W+K. Make sure your book is impressive enough.
也看看你学长能否帮忙,祝你好运~

dellsheng's picture
dellsheng
Activity Score 21

thank u so much.
你在4a工作吗?拉我一把吧!哈哈 我好想去实习

joelapompe's picture
joelapompe
Activity Score 3830

oh no pleaeeeeease Not again!!!!!

royschellekens's picture
royschellekens
Activity Score 390

Recycled milk

http://twitter.com/royschellekens

Hate advertising? Make better ads.

mynscl's picture
mynscl
Activity Score 32

what do you want from a bunch of guys that had been communisly brainwashed?

they don't creat,they just copy.

Sven Gali's picture
Sven Gali
Activity Score 845

BLAH

silvi's picture
silvi
Activity Score 4172

Not idea at all

nspad's picture
nspad
Activity Score 96

4.2? Really?

Mr.Zorba's picture
Mr.Zorba
Activity Score 25

i agree with you oso89 why dont you guys just make a students section in this website so they can post their normal works away from your highness stuff ?!!

devonj's picture
devonj
Activity Score 4

For very educated and knowledgeable people, i am surprised at how ignorant some of your comments are. Even if you don't think its original i think some of those comments are just plain unacceptable from professionals. Axl are you xenophibic or have a problem with chinese people? To the student, continue with what you are doing-the technique is developing well and i think great things will come from you in future -right now you copy to see if you can do just as good but in time you will become more original in your executions .

Brooklander's picture
Brooklander
Activity Score 42

Idea aside, I think the art direction looks excellent for a student. I know I couldnt of made it look that good when I was a student.
I like the positioning of the product and line which keeps it simple and clear. Well done.

michelangelo's picture
michelangelo
Activity Score 660

idea: overdone. art direction: ok. photoshop: ok. as a student work: keep it up

dellsheng's picture
dellsheng
Activity Score 21

thank u for all u guys' comments.

I don't want to explain anything about the copy thing,'cause I know as a AD student,I should know what's happenning in advertising,even I didn't mean to copy,but i have to admit that this is a copy.

达芬奇's picture
达芬奇
Activity Score 52

这个是用ps执行的么?我说那小人哈哈

设计生活

Ed Rapport's picture
Ed Rapport
Activity Score 724

So what if it's been done before.. if this is a students work, great job..

Advertisement