77 comments

Guest's picture
Guest

sorry but its an old idea and done for so many times

Nanel's picture
Nanel
283 pencils

hey you dumb guest commenter. it is "photoshop disaster" not "photoshop desaster". if you're going to trash some work make sure you use the correct words.

monicamexico's picture
monicamexico
830 pencils

Took me forever and the payoff wasn't worth it.

sneakyhands's picture
sneakyhands
1857 pencils

not great

Guest's picture
Guest

You know what no need no packshot... put the pen plus the line handwrittened on the paper.
Might give a little boost to the overall art direction.
Otherwise it "ok".

Guest's picture
Guest

Agree with Monicamexico.
You could also title it 'speedbumps' and it'd be easier to get.

funky_frogii's picture
funky_frogii
2536 pencils

funny....liked it.

infected by a virus called creative
http://addot.blogspot.com/

Infected by a virus called CREATIVE | "And ya I Love Everything"
http://addot.blogspot.com | http://creativecreepers.blogspot.com

Guest's picture
Guest

dai funky frogii...

Guest's picture
Guest

disaster...more disaster.

Guest's picture
Guest

good one.

Guest's picture
Guest

speed kills... so does boring classes

Guest's picture
Guest

good disaster

Guest's picture
Guest

simple...brilliant...mindblowing! Keep it coming whoever u are :)

Guest's picture
Guest

Intellectual stuff. Good one.

natesanmohan's picture
natesanmohan
25 pencils

Natesan Mohan
Good one.

Guest's picture
Guest

Done 6 years back!! !
Check the below link
http://www.coloribus.com/paedia/prints/2003/11/08/50982/

LeeHarvey's picture
LeeHarvey
3045 pencils

Okay that's clear then. Sue the bastards/copycats/frauds!

john ler's picture
john ler
667 pencils

LOL ! And already in India !

Guest's picture
Guest

Stop all these fucking scams and get real work done!

Guest's picture
Guest

SHAME REDIFF SHAME TO YOU.

Guest's picture
Guest

Simple and bang on. Sure winner!

Guest's picture
Guest

is this rediff calcutta?? is that you andy?? with piyash/anindyo??well... aaahhhhmmmm... i will hold my comments until i get the answers to the queries.
overall, not expected from you andy.

Guest's picture
Guest

WOW!

Guest's picture
Guest

Done well!

gbl's picture
gbl
451 pencils

Done before, in a much better way. Still cool idea.

Guest's picture
Guest

idea is not an idea until it marries the right art direction

Guest's picture
Guest

nice! nice! nice!

Guest's picture
Guest

Ideas are nothing but a combo of old ideas.

Good job people.

Guest's picture
Guest

Simple. Stark. And teases the brain.

Bravo Rediff!

Guest's picture
Guest

A clean layout. Simple idea well put across.

Kudos Guys!

Guest's picture
Guest

Great job. Well executed, keeping an element of curiosity.

Guest's picture
Guest

Great wrk. Keep it up ye. You guys want a job in Sao Paulo? :) - Giga Andrews

tirthomitro's picture
tirthomitro
2764 pencils

Well, I am not from Rediff, but I am very much interested in your proposition.
I am a CD with a creative boutique called "twohmp" (2 handled metal pan). and I would love to go to Brazil. not just the ads but the girls over there are great too.
so tell me how do i get in touch with you and take things forward...
looking eagerly forward to your answer.
thanks & regards,
tirthankar

they showed me a picture & i laughed
dignity has never been photographed

Guest's picture
Guest

Awesome. Ivan, can we see more such ads from asia? :) thanx

Guest's picture
Guest

Whoa! India rocks.

Guest's picture
Guest

hmmm...i will give it a 8.

Guest's picture
Guest

Fantastic! Rediffusion Chennai has done this?????!! Unbelievable....wht's happening there? Is this a new team???

Guest's picture
Guest

ha ha...same old team...just that they have stolen the concept from others as usual....its a old award winning concept...they have reused it...shame...cant you guys think new...what are you doing???

OGS's picture
OGS
6 pencils

didnt get it..hope the audience can..

Guest's picture
Guest

hahahaha...thts a real cute ad...real gud

BrettHeart's picture
BrettHeart
136 pencils

what happend here? The book is flying on the top...

[BrettHeart™]

Guest's picture
Guest

Hmmmm! N tis is wat u get when u stare into a blank piece of paper ;)

Gr8 idea!!!!!

Guest's picture
Guest

Superrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr People

Guest's picture
Guest

look closely Brettheart! Look closely Mate!

Whadddup!

Guest's picture
Guest

look closely Brettheart! Look closely Mate!

Whadddup!

Guest's picture
Guest

good job. keep making such brilliant ads.

Guest's picture
Guest

well well well... what do we have here

good show! good show!

Guest's picture
Guest

Wah! Wah! Wah! Wah! What an idea Sir ji?!

Guest's picture
Guest

i think what this idea is first. now i know. nice idea. I like very much.

Guest's picture
Guest

kewl! CONGRATS rediff...finaly sum gud wrk

Guest's picture
Guest

zimbly
neat

Guest's picture
Guest

NICE WORK! AWARD SURE HIT!

Guest's picture
Guest

yes, sure. and it already got one for JWT couple of years back. :)

Guest's picture
Guest

wow! wow!amzin stuff

Guest's picture
Guest

mind bender! gr8 idea

Guest's picture
Guest

not everyone can get it I guess
only for the intelligent
clever idea

Guest's picture
Guest

... rediculous.

Guest's picture
Guest

clever idea

Guest's picture
Guest

http://www.coloribus.com/paedia/prints/2003/11/08/50982/

check this out.....Meenakshi, have you and your guys not seens this add before....there should be some kind of authenticity in steeling concepts...shame

Guest's picture
Guest

copy cats copy cats....COPY CATS

Check this out: http://www.coloribus.com/paedia/prints/2003/11/08/50982/

Guest's picture
Guest

copy cats...copy cats.....
cant you submit some intellectual idea from your own hot pot....REDIFFUSION CHENNAI????

COPY CATS...check this link http://www.coloribus.com/paedia/prints/2003/11/08/50982/

Guest's picture
Guest

When did you surrended all you creativity REDIFUSION guys....waste of time, money and space...who are these new guys Kishore, Charle...this is 2002 award winning concept....cant you cook up something new

Guest's picture
Guest

hello copy writers from where in the world did you find the word "Ergonomically" ...but yes good one on old concept ...just as ok "COPY" work!!

Guest's picture
Guest

ha ha...same old team...just that they have stolen the concept from others as usual....its a old award winning concept...they have reused it...shame...cant you guys think new...what are you doing???

Guest's picture
Guest

too neat :) great job guyz...chennai is rockin huh? ;) we guys in bangalore need to be careful nw...hehe

Guest's picture
Guest

cute idea, nothing new, art direction could have been improved in my opinion.

Guest's picture
Guest

copy cats shame on you guys.

Guest's picture
Guest

nice

Guest's picture
Guest

awesom and clever idea! 1st look itself brings a smile on ur face...and whoever is writing the rude remarks atleast write in ur names! if u hav an opinion im sure u have a name!
this is to leave comments on the creative not on the ppl! so get professional guys!

Guest's picture
Guest

Lame benefit, lame idea, lame art direction.

Guest's picture
Guest

Simple.... great

Guest's picture
Guest

rubbish

Guest's picture
Guest

hmmm gr8 idea or simple, it did spark up some ulcers I guess :P

Guest's picture
Guest

Nobody has a data bank of all the freakin' ideas created in the world! Many a times we come up with a brilliant idea, produce it, release it and then figure out that it's been done sometime back. But that doesn't make any of us thieves. It's just that some brands are similar when it comes to brand promises/USPs. They are invariably end up being linked to a common thought-stream. Blame the manufacturer for that ;) Like for instance, super fast writing will lead to this idea. Maybe they stopped here, maybe if they had worked their grey cells a lil' more they would have landed on sumthin' "original". Maybe euphoria took over after they came upon this idea, maybe all of you great advertising "gurus" should stop behaving cheap by being abusive and immature by taking names and just let them be. You've made your point, they have got it. Atleast we should let them be for coming up with a newer way of executing it. Let's give them some credit for the idea and move on.

PS: Ivan anymore abusive remarks, you need to take a call. I understand good critics is allowed, but not taking names, spilling out "advertising" frustration by being abusive. I hope this site is not turning out to be another space like "hi5/orkut/facebook/myspace" for leaving comments. Pls do the needful. Thanks. - Raghu, Mumbai.

Guest's picture
Guest

^^ Yes, with fast writing, you would definitely need speedbumps... maybe a little bit more, but ah well, better need some improvement!

Guest's picture
Guest

when i got it, I liked it.
But I didn't get it fast.

Guest's picture
Guest

i didn;t get it :(

Log in or register to post comments