Related videos by Shutterstock

18 comments

STRTLRS's picture
STRTLRS
1607 pencils

Well done, very clear messaging, if not the most creative.

www.storytellerscreative.com

---------------
I think, therefore... yeah.

jsantanaxp's picture
jsantanaxp
397 pencils

Good point.
i rebember this.

-------------------------------------------
http://comunique9.blogspot.com

Michael Downs's picture
Michael Downs

While the concept is consistent, there's plenty of air between the two treatments.

izmild's picture
izmild
770 pencils

Good idea, but doesn't make sense! It's too imposed...

Guest commenter's picture
Guest commenter

Find the idea after having seen a photography is a crime. :-o

Guest's picture
Guest

why? Is it illegal to get inspired?

Javier Ramírez's picture
Javier Ramírez
1245 pencils

Chief Creative Director Nexus BBDO

Guest commenter's picture
Guest commenter

i don't like the idea, student work

D'uh's picture
D'uh

Abitebol, I don't think the ad you posted is the same as this one. Water puts out a match. What's clever about that? But in this ad a flame is encrusted in ice because of the cooling system. That's clever.

Some people need to learn how to tell the difference between a similar visual and a similar idea. In this case, it is not a similar idea.

SeanMartin's picture
SeanMartin

Normally, I'd agree, except the layout of the photo and the layout presented here are just a bit too uncomfortably similar. I dont think we can write this one off as a bad luck of the draw. It's pretty glaringly obvious the photo inspired the ad. This one might be taking it a step further, but the other is a clear copy.

--------------------------

No, I am not a media buyer.

thetruthfullguy's picture
thetruthfullguy

Soooo done before. By DM9 like a hndred years ago.

Guest commenter's picture
Guest commenter

I agree done a lot

Guest commenter's picture
Guest commenter

they needed 2 PHOTOGRAPHERS for this?

rachidbel's picture
rachidbel
8 pencils

Great idea

Guest's picture
Guest

one photographer one litho ;-)

Guest's picture
Guest

its a copy from another ad to conditioned air

Guest's picture
Guest

TThe reason why everyone has seen this is because the original ad was created by Platinum based in NYC and Brazil. This is just a very bad reproduction and the creatives should be ashamed.

Post new comment

Thank you for commenting. Please do not spam, be elaborate, respectful and helpful.
Log in or register to post comments