Advertisement

Comments (49)

Log in or register to post comments

Highest Rated

audyreza's picture
audyreza
Activity Score 105

the idea is great, but still... why show "before"

Shekh Imran's picture
Shekh Imran
Activity Score 14

Great job!

Olafski001's picture
Olafski001
Activity Score 1193

great job?
this is just stupid.
good execution? No it isn't.
Why show the before? you don't need that. It makes it complicated
this is bad
1/10

Guest's picture
Guest

wow!
"superb ad"

icanthink's picture
icanthink
Activity Score 270

superb work

R. Rinaldi's picture
R. Rinaldi
Activity Score 686

Consider it done.

getconnected2001's picture
getconnected2001
Activity Score 987

Nice and simple.Wow :)

iamcreative's picture
iamcreative
Activity Score 262

AWESOME!!!...exellent idea!!!

Adaddicted's picture
Adaddicted
Activity Score 3435

Simple and Great..!

withalltherespects

Alistair C.'s picture
Alistair C.
Activity Score 692

you can't be serious, this is even before first thought

Prof's picture
Prof
Activity Score 1449

Agree 100%

Quite really.

Heads's picture
Heads
Activity Score 194

At least someone who can judge an idea. It's 3/10 at most.

theanc's picture
theanc
Activity Score 2783

I also agree. And I believe that it's done many times before. Here in Brazil I saw something like this at least 5 times.

PORTUGUÊS: http://augustocorreia.carbonmade.com I ENGLISH: http://augustoinenglish.carbonmade.com

brain123's picture
brain123
Activity Score 830

I've seen this ad 3 times in student books...

esteb's picture
esteb
Activity Score 673

Be serious, this is a student work.

arvin's picture
arvin
Activity Score 341

Great idea!

arvin's picture
arvin
Activity Score 341

very simple

CR_AD's picture
CR_AD
Activity Score 413

Good, simple and effective, be it that that not was already make?

http://www.coupsdepub.com/

david.g's picture
david.g
Activity Score 68

it is a good idea in the past

.nl's picture
.nl
Activity Score 207

Not good today, not creative ever.

Audrius Kubrik's picture
Audrius Kubrik
Activity Score 828

simple, but a bit confusing because of the belts coming from different sides. i was mislead into thinking there has to be more. when i understood there wasn't i joined Alistair Craven's opinion. but is primitive simplicity so wrong when it comes to consumers? and even when something WAS done before it was done again does it become wrong or less creative? i'm not talking about stealing ideas, just accidentally (or inevitably) thinking the same way.

hhok99's picture
hhok99
Activity Score 13

I like it. And though it has been done before I actually think this execution was better.

Ghandour's picture
Ghandour
Activity Score 24

really it has been done before till death..i dunno whats new??!!! i think it would be good in 1992

NatalieM's picture
NatalieM
Activity Score 1685

So subtle. It works, but I agree that the belts coming from different sides makes the consumer think too much. Though we all have our vision, it must be easy for the consumer. They need to see it and get it. Instantly. I'm not saying the belts should be on the same side since that would make the ad trite. Merely placing them on opposite sides does not solve the problem, though.

Blaz's picture
Blaz
Activity Score 69

soooooooooooooooooo done.

Albondiga's picture
Albondiga
Activity Score 96

Pants

vaoleo's picture
vaoleo
Activity Score 81

Es bueno. pero no es fresco

STRTLRS's picture
STRTLRS
Activity Score 1601

Where's the buckle? Pants? Huh? Great work my ass.

www.storytellerscreative.com

---------------
I think, therefore... yeah.

Age's picture
Age
Activity Score 74
elMarto's picture
elMarto
Activity Score 23

Super boring!!

raverus's picture
raverus
Activity Score 1476

*below average

mmackinven's picture
mmackinven
Activity Score 1608

I really wish people would read comments before they comment "AWESOME, WOW" etc

As again, I've seen this many times.

Kateter's picture
Kateter
Activity Score 2029

crappity crap!

David Hasselblad's picture
David Hasselblad
Activity Score 120

DONE DONE DONE.

And the belts coming from two differrent sides make it confusing. Like you buckle your belt the other way around after losing weight..

Patrizio's picture
Patrizio
Activity Score 172

OMG: This is really boring. A thought any creative comes up after 5 minutes. And it's been done better many times before. With this idea we're moving backwards in creativity.

fifilo's picture
fifilo
Activity Score 74

To the point. Everybody understand it.

iamcreative's picture
iamcreative
Activity Score 262

Very clear & simple.
Good work.

kgeiger's picture
kgeiger
Activity Score 7312

Talk about reusing things. Both belts and ideas.

cold fire's picture
cold fire
Activity Score 60

Good work.

pankajadsoftheworld's picture
pankajadsoftheworld
Activity Score 433

This ad made me log in and leave comment.

A great ad...

"creativity is always one step back"

scorpio20's picture
scorpio20
Activity Score 30

repeat..

kulago's picture
kulago
Activity Score 101

copycat

TrainRunner's picture
TrainRunner
Activity Score 225

so they can afford a gym membership and not a new $5 belt?

simon.gross's picture
simon.gross
Activity Score 541

Welcome to the 80s.

JOJO04's picture
JOJO04

very simple and great idea.

Anutrivandrum's picture
Anutrivandrum

No need to mince words. Siju’s creativity at it's best as always.

Guest commenter's picture
Guest commenter

i love this idea.

Guest's picture
Guest

great IDEA.

audyreza's picture
audyreza
Activity Score 105

the idea is great, but still... why show "before"

Advertisement