Advertisement

Comments (23)

Log in or register to post comments

Highest Rated

jai hind's picture
jai hind
Activity Score 356

but this same idea was done in 2003-2004 in mudra delhi and incidentally for samsung only, i remember it as i were a trainee there and the CD who worked on it happened to be my boss there at that point of time

jai hind
art director

EtaKi's picture
EtaKi
Activity Score 121

What is this Etnhof Solutions? Samsung mobile phones are not even their account. Please remove this ad ASAP before legal action is taken. Mssrs Sangeeta and Suraiya, please watch some TV as LG mobile (our competition) is running a similar commercial on TV quite regularly. Doing something like this under the Samsung name ruins the image of the brand! Please refrain from using the Samsung Mobile brand name for your 'trivial' creative pursuits.

Ivan, please ensure the legitimacy of work sent in by your regulars as this could get into quite a legal hassle...even though we may not want this great site to be dragged through the trouble.

anny's picture
anny
Activity Score 10

chill man! i think this is a student work. and as per as idea and the concept are concerned, its simple and smart.

EtaKi's picture
EtaKi
Activity Score 121

Ah ok! Then let's have a separate page for 'student' entries....for all 'students' working in agencies!

digifool's picture
digifool
Activity Score 264

This is an interesting discussion. I understand the thought that the company should control their what their brand is.

But with the internet and the accessibility to software to create ads at home, that brand control is no longer in the hands of the marketing team. It's in the consumers. In reality that's where a brand should be. The consumer takes ownership of brand and it becomes embedded with in them.

Now the best any marketing team can do is learn to collaborate with their target audience. I wouldn't complain if someone is doing free work for you. To be honest with you this better than some the junk I've seen for Samsung. They are obviously fans of the brand and shouldn't be discouraged. Learn how to make it work for you. You can also learn a lot about how your brand is perceived and make adjustments accordingly.

I would however question how they are trying to pass themselves off as an agency. That's not good.

EtaKi's picture
EtaKi
Activity Score 121

I am sure you have read a few comments on the page before keying down your comments. Namely, the one with the web link (that's the blue coloured, neatly arranged alphabets that link you to other sites) that this is a 'genuine' copy from an older piece. Then, there is a part in my comment that says this is also lifted from a commercial (on air) for another cell-phone company in the country. These guys also live in the same country. You may like copies....but not every one has similar taste!

digifool's picture
digifool
Activity Score 264

Thanks Captain Sarcasm

I agree with you, dishonesty is not something I'm interested in either. Copycats are generally easy to spot (this is another advantage of the internet)and will get their own. I did misunderstand the situation a little here and I apologize.

That aside I was commenting on something larger namely the old world mentality of trying to control your brand like a fascist and there are brands that still do this. Lego once tried to get everyone to stop calling their product "Legos" (something that probably started with their core audience, kids) It just seemed petty and ridiculous and made them look silly. It could be argued that it would do them well to officially add an s on their logo and call it a day since the real owners of their brand are kids.

I'm just saying don't look like a fool by taking legal action on a couple of nobodies that likely screwed themselves over for a long time by posting this ad on ads of the world.

EtaKi's picture
EtaKi
Activity Score 121

No legal action yet, bro! But the site needs to differentiate between student work and mainstream work! It's not the kids' fault....more of the site!

Thanks for understanding my concern.

viky's picture
viky
Activity Score 358

bad bad bad bad bad.....
Photoshop

Student work

"Flooded with art"

corporal_hicks's picture
corporal_hicks
Activity Score 365

Very bad execution...

Bye's picture
Bye
Activity Score 1464

Remembered me of this: http://adsoftheworld.com/forum/exhibition/bookmark Someone pointed out seeing something similar for samsung, probably this, but also someone pointed out that it was done a long time ago for a watch.

adman007's picture
adman007
Activity Score 54

my boy, hallo, done dana done done before.

joestamp's picture
joestamp
Activity Score 130

for student work its not a bad idea at all,
agreed execution could be a bit better, but overall a good idea!
well done!

second_creator's picture
second_creator
Activity Score 754

liked it

copywriter

erhanali's picture
erhanali
Activity Score 368

Good idea. That is it.

"Everyday is one short life"

www.erhanali.blogspot.com/

capton john's picture
capton john
Activity Score 640

hum....Nice ad! It fits on both aspects concept & art direction. May be possible that this ideas had used in past but I liked it because its simple & smart.

Keep it up Dear!

Think, Act, Invent.
http://captonjohn.deviantart.com
http://captonjohn.blogspot.com

Think, Act, Invent.
www.narendrakeshkar.com

EtaKi's picture
EtaKi
Activity Score 121

You aren't in advertising...are you?

kalpesh78's picture
kalpesh78
Activity Score 2578

hey ivan I'd love to float a new website. it'll be fun.
Scamsoftheworld.
Lol. just kidding.

ideas....30 minutes nahi toh free.

TrainRunner's picture
TrainRunner
Activity Score 225

I don't know about India, but in the states not a lot of people put charms on their phones. 8 years ago they did, but not now. If the ad wasn't labeled "Charm" then the execution would have been lost. I enjoy the thought but some other execution would have been more effective.

raverus's picture
raverus
Activity Score 1476

student, next...

panasit's picture
panasit
Activity Score 687

I mean, you just don't do that to cell phone. There are other ways to show that it is thin. This is the kind of idea that may come up but get thrown out during brainstorming session.

-Tung
--good idea is enemy of great idea

gmint7's picture
gmint7
Activity Score 2683

:::J:::

i really like the idea though. it works as a thin usp.

but its done, sorry cheater.

and for the student thingy, if its published (either on public or jus student magazine), it is okay.
but if not, just simply label it student (or put the institute name)

and raverus, just because it is a student, doesn't mean it's bad. please be constructive (points a middle finger at you)

:::J:::

tinu.tg's picture
tinu.tg
Activity Score 12

nice idea!
bad execution...

jai hind's picture
jai hind
Activity Score 356

but this same idea was done in 2003-2004 in mudra delhi and incidentally for samsung only, i remember it as i were a trainee there and the CD who worked on it happened to be my boss there at that point of time

jai hind
art director

Advertisement