26 comments

Wordnerd's picture
Wordnerd
6662 pencils

beautiful ads. like them

sold's picture
sold
3219 pencils

i saw about 2 or 3 campaigns using this circular art...
but this is not important anymore.
i think this ads are ok, nothing more, nothing special (because i saw this art aproach before).

Stigset's picture
Stigset
1456 pencils

This is great :) It looks really good

Advertising Pawn's picture
Advertising Pawn
419 pencils

They look really clean and the photography conveys the idea of peacefulness well enough, however the idea feels a bit "tacked on", kinda like "Hey guys, I saw this cool FlickR set, for which one of our projects could it work?" (http://www.flickr.com/groups/createyourownplanets/)

http://advertisingpawn.com

_________________________________

Join the rarely updated ad orgy here: http://www.advertisingpawn.com

Wordnerd's picture
Wordnerd
6662 pencils

nah.. those two campaigns have nothing to do with each other

brain123's picture
brain123
830 pencils

Yeah, they might look alike, but the idea is totally different.

brain123's picture
brain123
830 pencils

Really nice idea. The photography is beautiful. Well done!

Bernardo Alberto's picture
Bernardo Alberto

As a lider, I think it's a nice Ad.

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOT

Bernardo Adalberto's picture
Bernardo Adalberto
Wordnerd's picture
Wordnerd
6662 pencils

Oh my, you're right! there were already ads using people!

Helloooo? do you know, what an idea is?? jeez

Ed Mintone's picture
Ed Mintone
585 pencils

I disagree, circular is so last month

GianT's picture
GianT
56 pencils

Stop whinning about people taking ideas of others, a lot of people knows how to do this effect with an image; the point is that idea is well suited for this kind of product, though it could have been worked better.
So what should people do? Make something clearly different of the idea they have, just because other people did the same effect, and this DESPITE it wasn't for the same purpose at all???
I'd like to see some of the *GREAT* and **NEW** ideas of some people on this site.

Vicky's picture
Vicky
375 pencils

The idea is O.k, but the product is really amazing, so the idea could be better.

CC3's picture
CC3

Seems like you could have taken this idea much further. C+ on AD - D+ on idea

trevoy's picture
trevoy

Hey, CC3. Seems like your critique could have been more well thought out. D for expression - E for any one giving a fuck about what you think.

CC3's picture
CC3

Oh, trevoy, this must be yours.

Here's some advice. Grow your skin thick. If you don't want an honest critique of your work, don't post it.

More importantly, grow up.

tjb1970's picture
tjb1970
488 pencils

why is everyone so in love with this campaign? it looks okay, but not much of idea, no?

Tincho's picture
Tincho
1093 pencils

Its a great technique and well executed to advertise this product, but how many of this ads are we going to see??... creatives are suppose to do original things, new things... If you know its done, then its done and you have to think something else.

fractalrene's picture
fractalrene
1506 pencils

Not bad at all. This is the beginning of something really good.

trevoy's picture
trevoy

No CC3, this is not my work and you, my friend, appear to be the one who needs the thick skin.
As I said, no one on this site cares what you think.

hyt's picture
hyt

I don't get it?

noduh's picture
noduh
20 pencils

They grab your attention but would work better if the people were in places that actually looked noisy.

Wordnerd's picture
Wordnerd
6662 pencils

don't think so. the noise would then be trapped with them in the bubble

noduh's picture
noduh
20 pencils

Okay. Agreed. Then it misses the mark a bit for me.

Log in or register to post comments