23 comments

juliangray's picture
juliangray
987 pencils

the message should convey very strong, but i think the ad is not up for it.

Its "warm" but aint burning. i need a stronger image for such a terrible crime.

The image just sais murder or violence in india in a too subtle way. But doesnt talk about the discrimination and hate crimes.

RM's picture
RM
419 pencils

What could be stronger than this image, please tell me?
It's the simplest, most direct piece of communication on this page, well done

digifool's picture
digifool
255 pencils

I love this ad.

adrianapr's picture
adrianapr
1238 pencils

this ad ROCKS. i like it very very much.
it IS strong, come on!!!!!!! we don't need to see a dead girl or something!

Tincho's picture
Tincho
1093 pencils

I like it. Powerfull and simple.

banana tom's picture
banana tom
40 pencils

Nice

ManchuChanchu's picture
ManchuChanchu
701 pencils

the idea of a 'bindi' looking like blood/gun shot is fine. but the execution (read photoshop job) is not good

adrianapr's picture
adrianapr
1238 pencils

why is it not good? i see a very correct art direction in this ad...

ad me's picture
ad me
5 pencils

Very westernised concept. Indians are not a trigger happy lot like the West. So showing a gun shot is a mismatch with girls being killed in India. Time to get the basics right buddy. Don't see the world through western goggles!

imke's picture
imke
472 pencils

I am touched with the message and ...ok visual too....

"No think is impossible"
---------------------------
http://mikeyonjan.blogspot.com/

sbrgs's picture
sbrgs
4 pencils

very nice

Olafski001's picture
Olafski001
1193 pencils

the idea is good but not great
the execution is ok but not good
so the ad is nice but not brilliant

J.Zdaniuk's picture
J.Zdaniuk
74 pencils

I agree with Olafski001, but I still wish I had it in my book.

Rajib's picture
Rajib
369 pencils

Strong.....

nitin456's picture
nitin456
133 pencils

ok

BorisTheSprinkler's picture
BorisTheSprinkler
24 pencils

sorry, but i've already seen this idea months before.
they did it for unicef i think.

Guest's picture
Guest

maybe unicef copied this idea!

BorisTheSprinkler's picture
BorisTheSprinkler
24 pencils

i don't think so.

i saw the unicef-ad ages ago. sorry dear guest: they were definitely first.

Nazim Abbas's picture
Nazim Abbas

Thats not a gun shot or westernized concept.... Women in India stick Bindi on their forehead thats red in color, its kinda accessory... And that bindi is round in shape and is considered very beautiful and i feel this ad shows the beauty of being a girl has become a curse for the girls ...

abbas.nazim's picture
abbas.nazim
19 pencils

Thats not a gun shot or westernized concept.... Women in India stick Bindi on their forehead thats red in color, its kinda accessory... And that bindi is round in shape and is considered very beautiful and i feel this ad shows the beauty of being a girl has become a curse for the girls ...

Signe_S's picture
Signe_S
357 pencils

Very strong idea!

abdou's picture
abdou
76 pencils

The idea is great, but the picture doesn't make a shaking effect. They should have made the drop go down on the side of the girl's face (which is more dramatic)and leave a thin trail.

On the other hand, India's major problem doesn't lie in foeticide... People there don't die because they are from a sex or another, but because they just don't find what to eat...!

Mr.Top's picture
Mr.Top
728 pencils

is ok

Log in or register to post comments