Romanian Association for Promoting Women's Rights: Woman, 2

Pick up the phone and save somebody! Call (0256) 293 203 and report domestic violence situations.

Advertising Agency: Mccann Erickson Romania
Creative Directors: Adrian Botan, Alexandru Dumitrescu
Art Director: Razvan Chifu
Copywriter: Catalin Dobre
Other additional credits: Raluca Iacob

Related videos by Shutterstock

22 comments

wildbore's picture
wildbore
749 pencils

....effective!

adsonly's picture
adsonly
136 pencils

i think its gone be like to everybody!

Olafski001's picture
Olafski001
1195 pencils

very good!

jazarah's picture
jazarah
1262 pencils

interesting, I like it

premc's picture
premc
917 pencils

very gud !

radical

ricklongo's picture
ricklongo
1244 pencils

As an adman, I think it's forced. But it's probably bound to be effective with the public.

Wordnerd's picture
Wordnerd
6662 pencils

Uuuuh.. Powerful piece of ad!

damselincombatboots's picture
damselincombatboots
9 pencils

Very nice and effective I would think.
Although it bothers me a little that when you hang up the phone, you're punching her in the face again.

Wordnerd's picture
Wordnerd
6662 pencils

good point! so make it an ad for the phone company. more money for them if people don't want to hang up again ;)

teenie's picture
teenie
1894 pencils

Good point--although it kinda says "if you don't help it's like punching her, too".

I like this. Very in your face and interactive.

A.G. Pennypacker's picture
A.G. Pennypacker
607 pencils

This was probably an effective piece for the client, but the ad guy in me says it's really, really ugly. The art direction here sucks. It looks like grade schoolers cut out magazine photos and glued them to a phone.

mafuta1's picture
mafuta1
13 pencils

I thought this was a great idea. When I saw it over a year ago in the book of a student named Karl Haddad while he interned at Saatchi & Saatchi London. It was done for the NSPCC child abuse hotline, one of their clients.

That agency happens to be very far away from McCann Erickson Romania. These ads are not "coincidentally" the same. They are blatant rip offs of his work.

I'm not even only talking about the concept and visuals either. Even the copy is the same!!

From Karl's: Pick up the phone and stop abuse
From this one: Pick up the phone and save somebody

Shame on all of you. This is a disgusting act of plagiarism...from a student book no less! The one thing I DO admire is that you actually had the balls to post this on the internet.

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

XL's picture
XL
214 pencils

Wow. That's a pretty convincing argument you make.

ahpitt's picture
ahpitt
342 pencils

wow, unbelievable!

For me, Creativity means impact + ORIGINALITY.

ooops's picture
ooops
448 pencils

head-pulling(WOW!)

elkatalinho's picture
elkatalinho
109 pencils

Trust me, it is a coincidence.

The fact that you come up with some sketches of a campaign that nobody knows and you make stupid accusations is really a thing that you should be ashamed about.

This campaign really existed? Nobody has even heard about it. Try thinking for a second before starting a world wide conspiracy theory.

Just to give you a taste of the conspiracy theory I could say that these sketches might as well come from your Photoshop, last night.

Please consider thinking next time before you launch yourself in false accusations. You put yourself in an embarrassing position.

LeeHarvey's picture
LeeHarvey
3045 pencils

Wow Catalin, someone stept on your dick obviously. I do agree that sometimes similar ideas are developed in different countries at the same time, or earlier. But your comment is way out of line, pointing the finger back. If I was in your position I would apologize and just say it was pure coincidence. Let's assume that is IS coincidence, then you should be glad with most comments, which say that it's a very strong idea. I do agree on that.

elkatalinho's picture
elkatalinho
109 pencils

I was only provoked by the annoyingly strong language.
Serenity now!

LeeHarvey's picture
LeeHarvey
3045 pencils

Agreed. Chill

gmint7's picture
gmint7
2685 pencils

:::J:::

i think it is not coincidence..
i wish both of them (student, CD) were here.. see what they throw each other... maybe a bloody deathmatch.

or maybe.. the students fail to sell the idea.and romania cd just happen to pass by the room.. ah!

:::J:::

dbrown6986's picture
dbrown6986
56 pencils

The student version was done almost two years ago. Frankly, the student version looks alot better also. It also doesn't require you to pick up the phone to get the message. Anyone passing by can see the CTA and understand/appreciate the ad w/o interaction. We don't need to see that she has a black eye. It's inherent. Wait, is he hitting her w/ the front of his knuckles in the "pro" version? It's more like a punch slap. I don't even think that would hurt! Coincidence or not, they've been called out and it will always be in question.

Guest's picture
Guest

I was just wondering how can an obviously fake ad (I never seen a handset in a shape of a fist - please look closely) increase "dramatically" the number of calls...

Post new comment

Thank you for commenting. Please do not spam, be elaborate, respectful and helpful.
Log in or register to post comments