Advertisement

Comments (18)

Log in or register to post comments

Highest Rated

Phil Indeblanc's picture
Phil Indeblanc
Activity Score 50

rather clever as student work, but multiple issues and problems as stated above.
So human civilization has boiled down to .."I rather own a dog since I don't have a child (for reasons XYZ), yet I 'll screw that up too. For those, I say keep having pets, not babies ;-P

tracyzhang's picture
tracyzhang
Activity Score 133

wow, now there's an app that nobody's thought of before....

trollster's picture
trollster
Activity Score 24
Ron Burgundy's picture
Ron Burgundy
Activity Score 1634

what a shitty idea...and by shitty i mean good

nice work

Ceballos's picture
Ceballos
Activity Score 621

Good work :)

alex valyukh's picture
alex valyukh
Activity Score 265

A pretty convincing way to make neighborhoods a little less poopy! Clever and nice!

have a nice day

Norremark's picture
Norremark
Activity Score 77

Very nice idea, but who will put the money into this idea? the bagel dude? with the economy as it is right now i think he would prefer to step in dog poo from time to time

Natgnat's picture
Natgnat
Activity Score 2

Nice Idea, but I'm quite puzzled.. do we need a profit to be civil?

logic's picture
logic
Activity Score 43

I never comment on this site but I'm starting to get sick of those miami ad school fantasy world case videos
Basically, this is saying that I can pick up 5000 bags, fill them with hot water (or pee in them for all i care) and get all the discounts i want? besides, it saddens me to think that all the ideas have to have a "get something in return" feature to change people's behavior. Don't get me wrong, the thought is nice, but we live on planet earth not in utopia, and i think miami ad school students need to learn that from day 1.

Nicely executed video though.

CrackerJackWorks's picture
CrackerJackWorks
Activity Score 18545

I disagree...when you're a student, the most important thing to demonstrate is that you can think creatively. The real world will come soon enough, and if you can think, you'll do well. That said, smart stuff.

yippy's picture
yippy
Activity Score 5

Totally agree with you CrackerJackWorks. Its a great student piece.

Glut's picture
Glut
Activity Score 3937

nicely done

atb2005's picture
atb2005
Activity Score 13561

I agree with Logic. This is totally phantasmagorical and as such impractical. This is the issue I have with a lot of the campaigns that come out of that school. Advertising is not just an exercise in creativity. Their case study videos though are always nicely done.

kleenex's picture
kleenex
Activity Score 43397

Best coupon EVER!!!

Bianconiglio's picture
Bianconiglio
Activity Score 406

I think corporal punishments would work better for those who don't clean after their dog.

Johnson.A's picture
Johnson.A
Activity Score 43

Giving rewards to people that are irresponsible doesn't solve the problem.
btw, poopon bags might get abused for free stuff.

Billoughsby's picture
Billoughsby
Activity Score 5144

This seems more like a project from Marketing 101 than ad/design school, and I think it fails because it is a weak incentivization program that has too many loopholes. Try again.

Points earned for good intentions only.

"Ubi hubave lubearned thubat ubanuby fubool cuban wrubite uba bubad ubad, bubut thubat ubit tubakes uba rubeal gubenubiubus tubo kubeep hubis hubands uboff uba gubood ubone."
-Lubeo Buburnubett

Unlocated's picture
Unlocated
Activity Score 6

good idea and clean way to get the message across. if only was sure that people wouldn't cheat!

Phil Indeblanc's picture
Phil Indeblanc
Activity Score 50

rather clever as student work, but multiple issues and problems as stated above.
So human civilization has boiled down to .."I rather own a dog since I don't have a child (for reasons XYZ), yet I 'll screw that up too. For those, I say keep having pets, not babies ;-P

Advertisement

20% Off Sale at iStock until December 9th 2016