25 comments

popdistortion's picture
popdistortion
1594 pencils

Not bad but what if the kid gets stuck or burns his bum?

act's picture
act
535 pencils

or pee...

Mo's picture
Mo
648 pencils

Pretty nice.

jkschlitz's picture
jkschlitz
48 pencils

That's a terrible Photoshop job.

act's picture
act
535 pencils

so now kids would think they can slide from their mums' hair anytime.

Desi's picture
Desi
1052 pencils

Hmmmm.....

ming the merciless's picture
ming the merciless
190 pencils

So am I looking at a Photoshop job or did it actually run?

the.adnerd's picture
the.adnerd
160 pencils

photoshop job

if the angle of the shot was a bit more to the side, hidding the front of the slide, the effect of the idea would seem nicer.

ming the merciless's picture
ming the merciless
190 pencils

I thought you had to post real ads on this site?

ivan's picture
ivan

I couldn't tell its photoshop, if it really is. Otherwise I try to post real things.

Ivan Raszl, admin of AotW

Lorem Ipsum's picture
Lorem Ipsum
49 pencils

she looks like mickey mouse

rupeshkashyap's picture
rupeshkashyap
6 pencils

Dear folks, this is not a photoshop job otherwise entire art are of this ambient could have been better. In fact, a huge cut-out of a woman with long hair was placed on the side of a slide to highlight the brand end benefit. it was targeted to women who frequent these children's park with thier wards.

the_ashlands's picture
the_ashlands
1394 pencils

sorry, but that is most definitely a horrible photoshop job..there is no way that is a big cut-out. just look at where it meets the sand....

pindaro's picture
pindaro
526 pencils

I don't think anybody here is questioning the value of the idea... most of the critisim is about the execution (whitch is lousy) presented to this forum.

Ofcourse is photoshoped, and a terrible one....Just look at the luminace of the hair and the values of blacks versus the rest of the picture.

the_ashlands's picture
the_ashlands
1394 pencils

we know this...but the poster was claiming otherwise.

justpassingby's picture
justpassingby
1368 pencils

Half of you probably couldnt come up with an idea like this. This is a very vlever use of media, whats wrong with everybody?! Stop your useless critisism.
And by the way, NO im not in the credit, ive never even been to India but i can spot a clever media spot. P&G are probably kicking their agency for not coming up with it first.

Ashindwe's picture
Ashindwe
10 pencils

pretty smart, but I don't think it would stop the traffic in my book.

nemesis's picture
nemesis
761 pencils

fake, fake, fake!

terrible photoshop job!

adabortion's picture
adabortion
615 pencils

Good idea to present as a proposal. Whether this is just a comp or not, well...
...the shadow of the cutout lady is missing ladies n gents!!!

morph's picture
morph
38 pencils

Sure is. At least this picture is not real. That doesn't mean it wasn't actually done. But i'm with everyone here who says this is a photoshop job. The lighting is wrong and, as the_ashlands points out, where the piece meats the sand is clear evidence that it was brushed out with 3px or somewhat feather.

Great ideia though! And really nice placing. When all the moms are waiting for the kids to get tired they find themselves thinking about their hair. Clever but fake photo.

swiss_adguy's picture
swiss_adguy
36 pencils

idea: thumbs up, way up! i am loving this shit…

maybe it was done, maybe it has been made up - like so many other ideas shown either here or at awards this looks just sooo fake.
however, when you present an idea, it should be as outstanding as possible, in this case, one must be blind not to see the huge difference in image density between the visual of the woman's hair and the rest of the pic.

conclusion:
presentation: thumbs down, hey, even the hands chopped off!

creativelefty's picture
creativelefty
50 pencils

nice idea yes, but as everyone says, its a bad DI job. If it really went through, why not take a photo of the actual location?

Capitalist's picture
Capitalist
132 pencils

Jelous Down dudes...let's talk about the idea. Perfect placement, the idea speaks tons...now,
what was the argument again?

drizae's picture
drizae
503 pencils

I hate the idea of such blatant advertising in a child's park.

Fail Harder.

comingsoon's picture
comingsoon
117 pencils

Great jobs!

Log in or register to post comments