Related videos by Shutterstock

12 comments

moonunit's picture
moonunit
125 pencils

Even if the thing at the back would actually somehow resemble a vacuum cleaner.. I'd still say NO to this one.

mgriff21's picture
mgriff21
592 pencils

Personally I think it's a very effective "non-traditional" form of advertising that's fun to look at and attention grabbing. Ambient is the direction that advertising is going.

Michael Griffith

www.mgadvertisingdesign.blogspot.com

I'm here doing this, but feel I should be there doing that. But to do that, I have to be doing this. Does this make sense or do I have to explain that?

Disco Munky's picture
Disco Munky
3900 pencils

Sorry to burst your bubble, but ambient isn't the direction that advertising is going. It will be a part of advertising but it's going to be more audience immersive i.e online

Doin' it for the points

Jet Propulsion Lab's picture
Jet Propulsion Lab
10683 pencils

Keep spewing that spiel every time you show this piece to a prospective employer. I'm sure they'll get a good chuckle out of it. I sure did.
I've been seeing too many student books jam-packed with "ambient" ideas with no real hard conceptual thinking to back it up. I'd rather see a rough sketch for a campaign idea that makes me want to say "Did you really come up with this idea? This is wonderful!"

Disco Munky's picture
Disco Munky
3900 pencils

Good idea. The execution could be different but that might just be down to personal taste.

It isn't trying to do too much which is good.

6/10

Doin' it for the points

CND's picture
CND
48 pencils

dude. griffith. that's your ad. geez. no wonder you think it's effective!

dbrown6986's picture
dbrown6986
56 pencils

Reminds me of the razor/zamboni thing that was on here not too long ago.

As a student, you should be more worried about strategy and less about cool ambient placements. Hoover vacuums clean stuff. No kidding. Show me a strategy for vacuums that I've never seen before, even if it's a line written in sharpie on a piece of paper, and I'd be more impressed than seeing this in your book.

brc912's picture
brc912
105 pencils

... Don't street sweepers do the opposite of a vaccum? It takes the dirt off the street by tossing it off to the side with a spinning brush. It has a possibility of a being a good idea, I just think that Hoover might be the wrong client for it.

krautland's picture
krautland
3225 pencils

did Michael Griffith get caught patting himself on his back? now that's seriously lacking style.

on the ad: it's decent but nothing that would make me think "shit, I gotta hire this kid right away" and that's what you need in your book. look, street sweepers are loud, huge and they just push the stuff out of the way. lots of gunk stays on the street. it's not elegant, it's not easy to operate, it's not doing a thorough job. it's also not a way I had never before looked at a street sweeper.

walk away from obvious other vacuums. your idea is that hoovers are thorough? then show me other thorough things that I've never connected with hoovers. do something surprising and most importantly of all do something undeniably TRUE.

finally: cut the explanatory copy to less than twelve words.

mgriff21's picture
mgriff21
592 pencils

Yeah. That did sound a little cocky. Not my intention at all! But I do appreciate the advice and direction you guys have given me. And no, actually this model of street sweeper does in fact clean the dirt off of the roads. It stores it in that big compartment in the back. But I do understand where you guys are coming from with the direction of using a different innovative media direction to support the message. That's why I'm still a "Junior Art Director." Thanks again.

Michael

I'm here doing this, but feel I should be there doing that. But to do that, I have to be doing this. Does this make sense or do I have to explain that?

AssassinX's picture
AssassinX
1329 pencils

Basically it's a good idea, however it's not great.
The idea is just based on one-step thinking which makes it not impressive enough.

Rog's picture
Rog
6094 pencils

Doesn't suck at all. ;)

>>>> That's not an ad. THIS is an ad.

Post new comment

Thank you for commenting. Please do not spam, be elaborate, respectful and helpful.
Log in or register to post comments