21 comments

someguy's picture
446 pencils
someguy

That's it. Advertising is over. You win. Let's all go home.

StPepper23's picture
267 pencils
StPepper23

brilliant, wonderful, incredible

Ordozgoiti's picture
237 pencils
Ordozgoiti

Really impressive.

sirvan's picture
29998 pencils
sirvan

Um. Guys? WTF?

Where's the turn? Where's the information? How do they communicate their message to the people who were intrigued by the flying people planes?

There has to be a SELL of some sort. If it doesn't, then it's an arts and crafts project.

Was there some follow up here we weren't shown? A handout? Something???

Sadly, this is either a poorly executed stunt. Or an absolutely terrible case study video.

Which is it?

+++

"I love some things, and don't love some other things."

simonds08's picture
624 pencils
simonds08

i first came across this stunt on yahoo's home page which had plenty of mention for both the movie and the agency. the video already has over 5,000,000 views on youtube after being up for only 4 days. if that doesn't constitute a success, than i do not know what does.

sirvan's picture
29998 pencils
sirvan

"David After Dentist" got 106 million views. And that sure sold a lot of… um…

If you go around proclaiming that views on youtube = success, you don't have long in this business.

Sorry.

+++

"I love some things, and don't love some other things."

simonds08's picture
624 pencils
simonds08

there is a key difference and you said it yourself. this video is promoting a product and was created for that particular goal. as i said before, this video appeared (was embedded) on the home page of major news websites with full articles detailing the purpose of the promotion. i imagine the majority of views came from within the pages of such news stories. if you do not think reach=success, you should go back to handing out pamphlets on the street corner.

Eugens's picture
2633 pencils
Eugens

we live in the digital age. the reach of the campaign was through the online talks about it, not through the actual stunt. it's really easy, and more convenient, if you think about it. why buy millions of flying people, then make flyers to explain to the guys on the ground what's going on, when you could do something nice, small, and with huge effects online. I'd bet this will get its fair share of lions.

thedesignaddict's picture
4857 pencils
thedesignaddict

@sirvan

I totally agree. I am still scratching my head. Sure 5.5 million people have seen the film, but were is the communication? Good viral should contain a message. This does not. If you go directly to the youtube film, the following text describes the video;

"Three human shaped RC planes were flown around New York City to create the illusion of people flying. Lots of fun."

This is not advertising, marketing or communication. It's 3 airplane enthusiast having fun on the weekend.

seizedlight's picture
18 pencils
seizedlight

Strongly agree. It is not advertising. Good viral should contain a message. This does not.

someguy's picture
446 pencils
someguy

The people that see the actual stunt don't really matter in the grand scheme of things. Google "chronicle flying people stunt" and you'll see the amount of earned media this sucker got. This movie is now on the radar of anyone that read those articles.

MicheleVirgilio's picture
2631 pencils
MicheleVirgilio

great idea and good realization

Blashyrkh's picture
30597 pencils
Blashyrkh

Just a mastered troll. Didn't know this was advertising.

kleenex's picture
16752 pencils
kleenex

Although the music was good this whole thing could have been done in less time.

Dharmesh aka danny's picture
334 pencils
Dharmesh aka danny

A good discussion had taken a new route here. My view: I enjoyed the video, but will not buy this.

Dharmesh Padia

Nike Diesel's picture
13048 pencils
Nike Diesel

I'm thinking the same. PR for PR's sake. Weak connection with the product and brand, if any. If so, I missed it.
Saw it a couple of days ago on a blog and didn't know it was advertising. Have to admit it's a nice idea.

Nike Diesel's picture
13048 pencils
Nike Diesel

I'm thinking the same. PR for PR's sake. Weak connection with the product and brand, if any. If so, I missed it.
Saw it a couple of days ago on a blog and didn't know it was advertising. Have to admit it's a nice idea.

Eight's picture
150 pencils
Eight

WILD !!!! outstanding.

Manoma's picture
1105 pencils
Manoma

SPLENDID !
And i agree with "someguy"... i go home ;-)

Temple's picture
9499 pencils
Temple

Novel. But it does lack connection.

ambareeshashirivaram's picture
102 pencils
ambareeshashirivaram

nice idea for teaser. and very good execution. and it's so effective to get response