37 comments

Guest's picture
Guest

Is there no Asian(!) people living in Bogota? I can't even imagine how this wouldn't get complaints.

Not Asian but still pissed's picture
Not Asian but s...

Of course this is racist!! And incorrect. People are not oriental, things like furniture are. People are referred to as Asian.

juliangray's picture
juliangray
987 pencils

In Spanish, oriental is a race. Even so, in english, being Asian doesnt mean one is oriental(orwhattever), it just indicates your place of birth, not your race.

klaussnow's picture
klaussnow
1675 pencils

aside from all that, who the hell says oriental anymore? Get it together, its the 21st century.

... its already been done...

alfredo's picture
alfredo
558 pencils

Wow. That's pretty racist.

Guest's picture
Guest

do you even know what "racist" means?
how is this racist?

pretty obvious idea, done 100 times before. and i doubt that people would attend to the shape of the glasses

hang-the-dj's picture
hang-the-dj
1262 pencils

Of course it's racist you fool. You don't have 'dictionary' installed on your computer?

Guest's picture
Guest

"Of course it's racist you fool. You don't have 'dictionary' installed on your computer?"

Ah, okay. You're just another moron who's incapable of producing arguments. Instead, you're getting nasty.

See, it's not racist to show different characteristics of different races. It would be racist if this happened in an insulting way. Go check your installed 'dictionary'
You think it's insulting to show "oriental" eyes? So please tell us: what's so bad about 'em? No proud asian with a normal self-confidence would consider this an insult.

hang-the-dj's picture
hang-the-dj
1262 pencils

You think that was nasty? You gotta get out more.

Please see ultraboon222's comment below, then tell me again this isn't racist.

Guest's picture
Guest

"You think that was nasty? You gotta get out more."
You know, I don't deal with curs and bums. That's why I expected a proper reply instead of your insolent one-liner. I'm sure you can be more polite if you try to.

I read ultraboon's comment. And I say this ad isn't racist.
First of all I don't know "ultraboon", nor do I know if she/he's Asian. If she/he is, I accept her/his point of view. But I'm still convinced that most Asians are self-confident enough to not take it as an offence. BTW, I wouldn't mind if an Asian agency did the same with e.g. long plastic noses attached to the 3-D-glasses for a European or US-American festival.

ANDRECHE's picture
ANDRECHE
56 pencils

!!

Yoli's picture
Yoli

Es una idea muy simpática con una gran ejecución!!

Daniel Rincon's picture
Daniel Rincon

i like it!!!!!! good good idea.

Delfondo's picture
Delfondo
86 pencils

Preguntamos: Cuantos Asiaticos vieron esa idea?, ojala que pocos porque si no los matan....Muy mala idea. De verdad muy mala. Lentes 3D?, nunca se utilizó en ningun lado. Un recurso muy usado. Pero más allá de eso la idea es MALISIMA!!!

J.BODE's picture
J.BODE

I think that it is simply good!

panasit's picture
panasit
687 pencils

I'm asian, and I think the idea is cute.

Come on, it's not like American has square shaped eyes of the normal 3d glasses.

-Tung
--good idea is enemy of great idea

OlivierM's picture
OlivierM

It's not exactly "Racist" it uses a "cliche".

So, for the next Colombian art festival in Japan, I'm pretty sure an operation called "Cocaine for everybody" won't be a problem.

And of course, DDB offers.

ad crazy 2's picture
ad crazy 2

so it's a cliché that asians have "almond-shaped" eyes?
sheeesh...
your comparison doesn't work.

Stigset's picture
Stigset
1454 pencils

I don't think this is racist, it just emphasizes a trait that asians have. Having such eyes is not an insult, it's basically like saying that scandinavians are mostly blond and africans have darker skin. Nothing bad there.
People should really stop this racism hysteria each time we talk about race traits; it's a bit tireying.
As to the ad i think it's a good idea, even though I'm not sure I would have understood immediatly that the shape illustrates asian eyes.

Guest's picture
Guest

so true. every single word. i second this comment. ^^

BOOBJOB LOOBCANNON's picture
BOOBJOB LOOBCANNON
1838 pencils

Shit ad.

Not racist just boring.

We're going to need more lube.

BOOBJOB LOOBCANNON's picture
BOOBJOB LOOBCANNON
1838 pencils

Actually, on seconds thoughts, it is stereotyping and derogatory.

Shame on you guys.

We're going to need more lube.

Guest's picture
Guest

que trucho tan berraco, que pena de pieza, que obvio, que cliché, que ganas de ganarse un premio...

kaceres's picture
kaceres
235 pencils

nice one

@Hazan_Ko

N\A's picture
N\A

esta pieza no resuelve lo que plantean como problema solo es un recurso adaptado a las malas.

el otro año será.

ultraboon222's picture
ultraboon222
220 pencils

As an Asian, I wouldn't want to be associated with this kind of ad. Yes, it only is the basic shape of the eyes of SOME Asian people but it's the connotation that goes along with it that are offensive. Just as you wouldn't pass out black maskes for an African American Film Festival, you shouldn't use racial "cliches" to promote the kind of event that is supposed to dispell such stereotypes. Personally my eyes aren't that shape and I'm Asian. I think that if you're not Asian, you would not realize how offensive this is. There's just too much negative connections associated with this kind of public display.

Point is, there's much better and smarter ways to go about this. And yes, things are oriental, not people.

Too many cooks in the kitchen....

hang-the-dj's picture
hang-the-dj
1262 pencils

Thankyou for putting it so succinctly, you are very right my friend.

I am not Asian but I certainly do realise how offensive this ad is.

Marcuss's picture
Marcuss

Que ignorancia DIOS!! porque hablan de racismo aquí, en ningún momento hay discriminación, ningún asiático tendría porque sentir que se le esta agrediendo. Es una muy buena idea que debe de simpatizar incluso más si sos asiatico, que tarados!!

junkbox's picture
junkbox

It is not about racist. It is about originality.
This one, is the first idea for everyone who work in advertising for a couple of months. Not enough work in it. Period

puppiepoppy's picture
puppiepoppy
1634 pencils

The pair of glasses were reminiscent of the shape of Creative Director's brain size.

Guest's picture
Guest

estos es racista para los acomplejados que en vez de apreciar y estar orgullosos de las carectiristicas de su raza tienen verguenza de si mismos. La idea no es lo maximo, es basica, ok...ese es otro punto. Pero no es racista. como no lo serian mascaras negras para un festival Afro Americano...si uno es negro es negro, aceptenlo. Si las mascaras fueran blancas para un festival Europeo seria racista?

CHIRSS's picture
CHIRSS

DIFFERENT, it's GOOD!!!!!.it is a novel invitation.

cortescreativo's picture
cortescreativo
118 pencils

a mi me gusta mucho la pieza, mil veces mejor que entregar un volante convencional, es directo y bien relacionado con cine. felicitaciones.

(miguelandréscortés / Art Director / Leo Burnett Colombiana)

(miguelandréscortés / Graphic Creative / Y&R)

ANDRECHE's picture
ANDRECHE
56 pencils

Hey miguel Muchas gracias!!!

N/A's picture
N/A

difiero de miguel. y de el alivio de andreche.

un volante podria ser mil veces mejor que esta pieza. que no resuelve el problema que plantea. en ese sentido no sirve. serviria mas un volante por malo que sea. no basta con relacionarlo con el cine eso no es la idea.

asi no vamos a llegar a ningun pereira.

lo siento.
me parece así.

Chris's picture
Chris
1985 pencils

englesa please

Chris's picture
Chris
1985 pencils

englesa please

Log in or register to post comments