Jump to navigation
I was fed up to repeat the same thing every time someone posts a bad PSA ad so here it is for once and for all. =)
That. You sir, are the voice for the future.
haha nicely done buddy
You do realize this is a PSA ad don't you? ;)
I agree 100% with you.
Unfortunately I am forced to create a PSA ad for class so I apologize in advance for when I post it up on here for critique.
Yes, a PSA to finish them all.
Good luck with yours =)
No one cares about child labor, eye donation or saving the Earth: NO PSA!!! http://adsoftheworld.com/forum/135094
One ring to ru– okay, I'm done.
Weirdly enough, soon after having posted this, PSA ads seem to be poping everday on the forum..... :(
And a condom ad.
you have a lot of typos or grammatical mistakes or whatever they're called in there
I'm just going to bump this, the message hasn't gotten through yet.
Great advice, btw posted my first PSA just before reading this. Next may be a product as you suggested :)
Hey CP, why don't you go make one of these for products where the emotion is already built in? PSA's have a lot to do with that as well, but the larger picture is that condoms, beer, jell-o, hot wheels, etc. are already fun and don't offer the CW/AD a chance to develop a unique voice for the product or get creative with their marketing. So basically, stay away from stuff that is already fun, emotional, or that you don't have to think about strategy for. Because execution isn't nearly as important as strategy.
Well, as a new entrant in this wonderful and creative ad world, I do think that for a person like me the PSA'S are great way or the only way to start and show the 'talent' you got. Creating a dummy ad campaign for an established product is like advertising that product without any cost.
I respect all the views but I think this is the only way I can start and hopefully get noticed by someone.
As a student, you should especially stay away from PSA campaign. Chances are that you will come up with the same "first ideas" tha millions of students already came up with for the last 4 decades (like the cigarette/gun thing, for example)
The idea of spec ads is to show the work you would produce if you were working for a real agency. While you might get some PSA work at an agency, odds are what you're going to be selling is toilet paper and shampoo. You can't say it's like working for free, because in reality your ads are still speculative--they will never be reproduced, printed, or otherwise used by the companies whose products you wrote them for. It just functions as a demonstration of your skill.
If you're concerned about one of your ideas being stolen, then at least you have proof that it was yours originally. Most respectable ad agencies don't need to steal junior work to pay the bills anyway. And if your primary concern is getting noticed (in a good way), then you should stay away from PSA ads. Nearly every printed or online source will tell you this. This is not an opinion, this is a fact that any decent agency does not want to see ads for products where the emotion is already built in. It's easy to get people on the bandwagon to stop murdering baby seals, it's much more difficult to convince people that their deodorant isn't as good as what you're selling. Don't take the easy route, because everyone in this industry knows how easy it is.
If you want, you can come up with a fictional brand of product. "Tickey's Toothpaste" or something.
I particulrly like the second part of your ad. Valid points.
marvelously done. thanks
Am also fed from seeing this ad again and again, where did you get it from Shawali? and why you always put it up when you want to comment on any PSA campaign??
Where did I get it? I made it.
And I don't "put it up". Some people feel the need to bump it up every now and then and use it to comment on bad PSA. Maybe because what it says is true.
Have a good day.
oh finally i understood, y not to experiment on PSA's. THANK YOU shawali.
you should make poster size prints and sell them on ebay/amazon
"I don't live in Greece, Greece lives in me..."
Haha, why not! Good to have you back.
Developing PSA is also a part of creative exercise whats wrong in that.Most student start with the PSA also
"Most student start with the PSA also"
That's exactly what's wrong with that.
How can I share this on my FB page? I love it. Can I have permission to copy it, share it discuss it on my blog http://www.insidethatad.com/?
Feel free to post it wherever you want. Spread the word!
The brief no one wants in the agency is the one you should take. Every brief, every product, every client has an opportunity to produce something of genius. Yes the first 99 ideas you have probably have been done before, so keep going....and going... and going. If you take on the easy briefs how will you improve? Just my two-cents. I don't think you should shy away from anything.
Fair point, though this post is about spec ads and is aiming at mostly students, who have a tendency to do a lot of spec PSA.
Also, I feel that PSA briefs are the kind everybody wants =)
I love CSR and PSA campaigns, give you freedom to imagine and think of others, BIG fan!
This is a great piece. Informative and beautiful! I hope everyone in advertising will take a look at this.
It's midnight. Do you know where your cookies are? Someway they're right underneath you. Others try not to even think about it. --Target
Why is it an issue that PSA's have been "done"? I think the first criterion must be "moving or not". Remember, it's in the public interest, so people will never ask if it has been done before.
Well, except if the earlier work has failed.
Nice design, but you know what I hate more than student-made PSAs? Art directors who don't bother to use a copywriter:
Copy/paste into your layout to fix. YWIA:
PSA campaigns (or one-shot ads) are the plague of any portfolio. Save the tigers, water, paper, Earth, kids! Don't drink and drive! Even the infamous cigarettes are harmful to your health—yes, we've really seen that one—have been submitted to the Exhibition forum on a daily basis. 98% of the time, they are visually, conceptually, and strategically total and utter crap. That doesn't necessarily mean the person who created them are terrible at making spec ads, but
JUST REALIZE THIS
Every day, all over the world, loads of top-notch agencies with a full staff of award-winning creatives and strategic planners work their asses off to create innovative 360 PSA campaigns. And even they can have a hard time doing so sometimes.
Also, campaigns against alcohol or cigarettes, for example, have been created on a daily basis FOR DECADES.
See what you're up against?
As a student or beginner in the business, the odds of coming up with something remotely unique are pretty slim. Not that's in impossible. But it's pretty damn close.
So don't waste your time trying to come up with a new, cheesy "don't drink and drive" print ad or whatever injustice your bleeding heart told you to raise a wrathful fist against. Chances are, it's been done before. That other idea you had? Done already. And that one? Done. OK, but this one? It was already in DDB's trash back in 1995.
INSTEAD, focus on basic, day-to-day products. Make a cool campaign for plastic gloves or washing powder. The plainer the client is, the more creative the strategy has to be. That's what creative directors will judge your portfolio on.
Haha, thanks for taking the time for correcting the copy =)
To be fair, English isn't my native tongue and I didn't have any copy writer, let alone an English speaking one, at the time. So I did what I could. But it's not too bad for a froggy, isn't? =)
I'm a student and now I'm definitely staying clear from PSA thanks to these constructive comments. I usually just make unofficial spec ads for products and services offered by brands, or just make up a product with a particular benefit.
That's the spirit!